THE DAILY NEWSLETTER  - MONDAY, OCTOBER 19, 2020

Media Winners & Losers

MEDIA WINNER:
Brian Stelter

CNN's Brian Stelter and his latest Reliable Sources panel agreed that Steve Scully and the Commission on Presidential Debates suffered a blow to their credibility in light of the C-SPAN director’s false hacking debacle.

On Sunday, Stelter discussed the media's relationship with President Donald Trump and the right in general. Speaking with TIME’s Charlotte Alter and Daily Beast Editor-in-Chief Noah Shachtman, the panel took on the subject of Scully's suspension from C-SPAN, and how that affects both perception and the ability of the media to moderate debates and more.

“How much damage does this do to the national news media as a whole when you have a prominent journalist admitting to lying under pressure?” Stelter asked Shachtman at one point.

Shachtman began his answer saying Scully is “not the first prominent journalist to lie about some tweet he was no longer proud of” and “not the first prominent journalist to claim to have been hacked and then not.”

From there, Shachtman continued by saying “it’s really got to stop” with journalists coming up with “ridiculous” explanations to try avoiding accountability for their errors.

“Yeah, it definitely does damage,” Stelter agreed.

That may not seem to be much of an admission or criticism, but it was a pretty important point to make, and especially to make on CNN. The credibility of the media isn't just an issue for one side, nor just a political talking point. It matters.

You cannot inform if you aren't believed. And Americans need to have a reliable source for information they can trust. Otherwise it's all just a battle over "fake news."
 

MEDIA LOSER:
Scott Atlas

Dr. Scott Atlas, top coronavirus pandemic advisor to President Donald Trump and Stanford University fellow, has been contentious and at odds with the other experts and officials heading up the national Covid response since the moment he came on the scene.

And as it turns out, those other experts - notably Dr. Deborah Birx - have become so fed up with it as to confront the Vice President about getting rid of him, a new report revealed on Monday.

In his time at the forefront of Trump-land's public Covid face, Atlas has called congressional testimony from CDC Director Dr. Robert Redfield not believable, accused NIAID Director Dr. Anthony Fauci of pushing a false narrative, tweeted something so diametrically opposite of his own task force and administration's recommendations that it was removed by Twitter, and has been revealed to actually oppose widespread testing in favor of a "herd immunity" theory one expert described as "the most amazing combination of pixie dust and pseudoscience" he's ever seen.

But it is the Washington Post's story that really puts Atlas in today's bad job spotlight. 

"Birx recently confronted the office of Vice President Pence, who chairs the task force, about the acrimony, according to two people familiar with the meeting," the Post reports, adding that Birx "told Pence’s office that she does not trust Atlas, does not believe he is giving Trump sound advice and wants him removed from the task force."

Atlas disputes every bit of the article, saying it is "filled with overt lies and distortions to undermine the President and the expert advice he is being given," and denying his herd immunity overtures which are on the record. Birx, however, has not disputed it.

Which says a lot, and none of it plays well for Atlas.

EXCLUSIVE: Fox News Passed on Hunter Biden Laptop Story Over Credibility Concerns

The A-Block

Trump Goes to War with Fauci

In an interview with Dr. Jon LaPook on 60 Minutes, Dr. Anthony Fauci said the Trump administration has been "controlling" his media appearances. 

The interview aired last night. Today, on a conference call, President Donald Trump went ballistic on Dr. Fauci, referring to him and other infectious disease experts as "idiots" that people are "tired of hearing" from. He also called Fauci a "disaster."

Later, he mocked Fauci's opening pitch and coronavirus mask.

Also the press

It wasn't just Dr. Fauci facing fire from Trump. The president went off on the media, of course, while holding a tarmac press scrum, ripping NBC’s Kristen Welker and  Savannah Guthrie as well as C-SPAN's Steve Scully

Then he called a reporter a criminal for not reporting on the New York Post's story about Hunter Biden.

Toobin

Jeffrey Toobin has been suspended from his job as a staff writer at the New Yorker , and has been "granted" some "time off" from his duties as CNN's chief legal analyst, after he apparently exposed his penis during a company Zoom call.

G'daaang

New Zealand journalist Tova O’Brien has become a viral sensation for her utterly brutal interrogation of an ousted politician that was clipped and shared online over the weekend. It's a must-watch.

Rhetoric

ABC’s George Stephanopoulos on Sunday pressed Republican National Committee Chairwoman Ronna McDaniel hard over President Trump egging on his supporters as they rail against Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer.

Whitmer responded to the recent rhetoric during her appearance on Meet the Press.

'Ill-advised'

John Oliver roasted Trump's plan to withdraw from the World Health Organization (WHO) during Sunday’s Last Week Tonight — blasting it as one of the “dumbest things we can possibly do.”

Lemon Cube

CNN anchor Don Lemon criticized Ice Cube for his involvement with President Donald Trump’s presidential campaign, causing the rapper to lash out on Twitter and issue a challenge to meet on Lemon’s show.

Must See Clip

Are you ready for softball questions?

Saturday Night Live‘s cold open mocked the dueling Presidential town halls this weekend and it was cruelly funny, but also makes you think.

"Are you ready for softball questions from folks who are already voting for you?" asks Mikey Day as George Stephanopoulos. 

“You bet your short pants I am,” answers Jim Carrey as a madcap Joe Biden.

Also Trump stuff which was funny!

THE INTERVIEW: CBS News White House Correspondent Paula Reid talks Covid, her viral clashes with Trump, and how Kayleigh McEnany compares to her predecessors ...

Links We Like

The New York Times' Slack is "totally weird" says Ben Smith.
- Alex Kantrowitz, via OneZero
Jamelle Bouie's silly attack on Amy Coney Barrett and constitutional originalism
- Dan McLaughlin, via National Review

The most important election ever... Again
- Jay Caruso, via Washington Examiner

David Perdue's mocking of Kamala Harris' name becoming self-own to end all self-owns
- Zack Linly, via The Root

 
Reading this online? Why not get it in your inbox? Sign up for the Mediaite Live from the Greenroom Newsletter today!
Twitter
Facebook
Visit Mediaite
Copyright © 2018 Mediaite LLC All rights reserved.

Write to us:  tips@mediaite.com

Problems with these e-mails? Update your preferences or unsubscribe from this list.