Email
Peter Dutton believed he was on a winning streak and nobody told him he was wrong until it was all too late. It was echo chamber politics, pure and simple, writes Joe Hildebrand.
View in browser 2nd May 2025
 

image

Joe Hildebrand
Federal election correspondent

My best mate is the smartest person I know and has one of the sharpest political brains I have ever encountered.

Engage him in any debate and he will present a towering case, a great tapestry of logic that stitches together a mountain of evidence and lays the whole job lot at your feet as an impenetrable and indisputable fait accompli.

Then he will pause for a moment and add: “Of course I could just as easily argue the opposite…”

It sounds a simple thing and perhaps it is, but it is also vital.

And it is also something the Coalition clearly forgot to do.

There is every indication today that the Opposition is heading for an electoral bloodbath. 

The latest YouGov poll is predicting the Albanese government will actually increase its number of seats to 84 while the Coalition will go backwards to 47.

An exit poll in Dickson conducted by The Courier Mail suggests Peter Dutton could even lose his own seat.

While such apocalyptic predictions may be inflated, it is clear the Liberal leader is about to have a very bad day at the office.

Only a few months ago the Coalition was riding high at 52-48 two-party preferred and was favourite among the bookies to win the election. Today it is facing a possible wipeout.

And so where did it all go wrong?

Already there has been bitter fingerpointing within the Coalition camp — or its two opposing camps to be precise — while others will blame everything on Trump or the media or Labor lies.

But ultimately it comes down to my mate’s absolute maxim: Always test every argument with the opposite argument to see if it still stacks up.

FULL LIST: WHERE TO VOTE TOMORROW

imageWarren Brown takes a look at Anthony Albanese's confidence as election day looms. SEE THE LIGHTER SIDE OF THE CAMPAIGN HERE

INTERACTIVE: Don't know who to vote for? Election MatchMaker is here to help

Dutton and his team clearly believed they were on a winning argument and had nobody telling them they were wrong until it was all too late. It was classic echo chamber politics, pure and simple.

And the problem with echo chamber politics is that it is incredibly alluring, like those deep sea fish that use a pretty light to attract their prey only to crush their jaws around the unsuspecting morsel.

It starts by being surrounded by people who say your default position is correct and don’t challenge your beliefs or your arguments.

You then feed these ideas to your base, these days almost entirely through social media, and of course they immediately resonate with the people who already agree.

CLICK HERE FOR JOE HILDEBRAND'S FULL ANALYSIS

Election update
Peter Dutton has been a classic victim of his own echo chamber
Peter Dutton believed he was on a winning streak and nobody told him he was wrong until it was all too late. It was echo chamber politics, pure and simple, writes Joe Hildebrand.
READ MORE  
Labor insider’s stunning poll tip for Dutton as PM heckled on Voice
Former Labor powerbroker Graham Richardson says he can still see a pathway to victory for Peter Dutton and the Coalition, despite what all the opinion polls are saying. It comes as...
READ MORE  
My partner must be PM – for more reasons than you think
Kirilly Dutton and Jodie Haydon explain in their own words why the man they love is the right person to lead Australia for the next three years.
READ MORE  

VIDEO OF THE DAY

imageBob Katter turns 80 next month, but he’s fighting his 12th federal election with the same vigour a western brown snake brings to a goanna attack. Today, he takes us inside his world. 

WATCH THE VIDEO HERE

image

Read more
Two Ds, three Cs … and one A: Albo’s performance report card
Cost of living has dominated the Albanese Government’s first term in office, but how has the PM fared in other areas? FULL REPORT CARD
READ MORE  
LISTEN: Brethren sect’s explosive leaked election Zoom call
An explosive leaked Zoom call featuring members of the Plymouth Brethren Christian Church has revealed the election tactics of members on polling booths. HEAR THE AUDIO
READ MORE  
Revealed: The key seats that will secure election victory
Labor may be leading the Coalition on the national vote, but privately both parties believe the contest will be tight. Election analyst Tom Connell reveals the seats to watch on Sa...
READ MORE  
BS detector: Albo and Dutton come out swinging in final pitch
Anthony Albanese and Peter Dutton explain to the Australian people why they deserve the chance to serve as prime minister for the next three years.
READ MORE  
‘Hate to say it’: Ray Hadley’s final say on the election
Ray Hadley has his final say before the federal election, hitting out at the Teals and looking at what might happen in tomorrow’s vote.
READ MORE  
Teal trio don’t practise what they preach on donations
Three Teal MPs who have advocated for real-time disclosure of political donations are leaving voters in the dark about who is funding their campaigns.
READ MORE  
FULL LIST: Top seats with highest pre-polling rates
See the top seats where millions of Australian voters have already cast their vote. Check your own electorate with our interactive list.
READ MORE  
Bob Katter’s wild, unhinged world: He’s had enough and wants to ‘strangle a bastard’
Bob Katter turns 80 next month, but he’s fighting his 12th federal election with the same vigour a western brown snake brings to a goanna attack. Today, he takes us inside his worl...
READ MORE  
Albo’s big power move as exit poll shows Dutton in danger of losing own seat
Anthony Albanese has swooped in on Peter Dutton’s electorate this morning, while the Opposition Leader has dismissed exit polling predicting his demise as “notoriously inaccurate”....
READ MORE  
Your next trip overseas could cost more – we’ve been left blindsided
The next time you go overseas you could be hit with a new cost – here’s where the money will be going.
READ MORE  
Where to find a Democracy Sausage near you
As voters prepare to cast their ballots on Saturday, here are all the locations you can snag a Democracy Sausage. SEARCH OUR INTERACTIVE MAP.
READ MORE  
LISTEN NOW: MP who loves The Beatles, ‘The Gambler’
We have asked Australia’s MPs what their top five songs are on the election trail and one MP has a few surprising hits on her list. LISTEN NOW
READ MORE  
Don’t know who to vote for? Take our two-minute quiz
Struggling to cut through the spin? Can’t work out whose policies are better for your family? With a simple swipe left or right, Election MatchMaker will solve your dilemma. USE IT...
READ MORE  
Where and when to vote to avoid Magic Round chaos
NRL Magic Round is set to attract plenty of fans – and Aussie voters. Here is what you need to know.
READ MORE  
Best of our election race cartoons
These are the best illustrations from our cartoonists who capture the funny side of what’s going on in the federal election race. SEE THE PICTURES
READ MORE  

Newsletter

AS NEEDED
Breaking News Alert
Never miss a story that matters to you. Get informed as important news breaks in SA and around the world.
Newsletter sign-up   ▸

Newsletter

DAILY
Sport Daily
Love your sport? Catch up with fresh news and exclusive reports every morning.
Newsletter sign-up   ▸

Newsletter

Every Tuesday
SA Business Journal
Your weekly digest of the stories that matter to South Australian businesses and consumers.
Newsletter sign-up   ▸
The Advertiser app: SA’s best news now has daily recipes too
The Advertiser’s app for smartphones and tablets is the best way to stay in touch with the news in South Australia – and now we can inspire your cooking and baking, too.
READ MORE