Call Notes: Box CEO Aaron Levie On AI’s Business Potential and Who Gets Ahead

Insight on Big Tech’s latest AI moves and some answers to major questions about jobs and creativity.

Box CEO Aaron Levie has an uncanny ability to explain complex tech moves in simple language. Whether it’s Meta’s decision to open source an AI model or Apple’s plan to build its own ‘Apple GPT,’ Levie gets to the bottom of issues fast. And so, in a week filled with major news, it was time to get on the line.

This week, I spent an hour with Levie — recording a special edition of Big Technology Podcast that’s releasing today (Apple, Spotify) — and we went deep into the tech giants’ recent AI power plays, discussing their moves and tackling broader questions around jobs and creativity.

Below are the highlights from our conversation, edited lightly for clarity.

Here’s Levie on…

Why some believe Meta open sourcing its large language model, Llama 2, is meant to harm competitors

If you can reduce the proprietary nature of your competition's technology stack and commoditize that for the market, on the margin, you might be able to reduce some of the value proposition, or some of the competitiveness, your competitor might have. It's probably a little bit of a stretch in AI right now for Meta, since they ultimately just want more usage of their platforms, and AI can be a contributor to that. So, I think the take is probably, if they can commoditize something Google is otherwise going to make proprietary, or charge for, there's some kind of game theory in that.

Meta’s most likely reason to open source the Llama 2

Open sourcing brings in great talent. It puts Meta at the top of the food chain in terms of leading technology companies. It has everybody studying their technology and their models. They become more of a standard bearer for the industry. That all generally accrues good things.

Whether people actually want chatbots, no matter how good the AI performs

The challenge is you're always competing with a powerful graphical user interface where in just two clicks, without any verbose typing, you can get exactly that same answer. I think the jury's out, to be totally honest, on what the form factor ultimately will be, for a lot of these AI interactions.

The clear enterprise application for generative AI

In a lot of enterprise use cases, you're not competing with a graphical user interface, you're solving a problem that could not be solved previously. In our business, you could not go to a data set of information, made up by documents, ask that dataset a question, and have an AI model actually answer that question. It just was not possible. This was not something search could even do. Now, these large language models, combined with this idea of a vector database, can solve that problem.

Where Apple might compete with its rumored ‘AppleGPT’ project

Their play should should be pure utilitarian. It shouldn't be a social thing. You should be able to grab your phone and just say, ‘Hey, can you order me a pizza,’ and then a little dialog comes up, and it says, ‘Hey, here's where we're going to order the pizza from, click Yes.’ That seems like the most obvious thing on the planet that Apple should just do. Or, ‘Hey, please write down a note for me to go do this thing, and remind me later,’ and it just gets it right every single time. Obviously, that's just like Siri plus plus. But I think Apple has both the device and the software prowess for it. Maybe they were late to large language models in this current ilk by nine months or something, but the good news is that everybody's still buying their phones. And I think people would switch overnight, if there was an integrated application right on the device. If they put their mind to it, and the use case was a smart assistant on your phone that could do everything, I would be very optimistic.

Subscribe

Why AI companies struggle to build moats

It seems pretty tough to be an AI model trainer, unless you are Meta, Google, Microsoft, OpenAI, or Anthropic. And you definitely don't want to be one of these pure thin interfaces on top. You've got to really establish a high degree of value, and probably workflow, and a data moat associated with your product.

Microsoft vs. Google’s AI office productivity software competition

Any midsize enterprise on up will not make the switch on the basis of AI pricing. So if you're a 5,000 person company, and you're already on Exchange, and you're already on Office, and you're already on Teams, AI will not be the determining factor for switching out your entire infrastructure. Microsoft knows that, and they're in a good position to benefit from the stickiness of their platform.

Is ChatGPT getting dumber?

The core novelty is now over. Now it's actually, ‘Are you telling me very useful, reliable information?’ Our level of criticality has just gone up, because there's no novelty factor overwhelming or outweighing the critical component that we wouldn't have had nine months ago.

A practical view of AI replacing jobs

Right now, these things can do one discrete information-oriented task, basically, at a time, before they need a human to review what they've done, and then move to the next thing. There’s just not that many jobs relegated to only one kind of thing. Even in the scenarios where people have tried to say, ‘The paralegal job could be automated’ it's just simply not true. These job functions are pulling together too many functions across email, and a community, and another communication tool, and a manager, and going into some other system, and then reviewing something, and then writing something. We're just nowhere close for the AI to successfully wrap all those scenarios together. The cost of an error is so high that no one is willing to put that liability on the line.

Will AI harm or help creativity

If you're a director, or a cinematographer, and you have to figure out what shot you want to do for some film, you spend X amount of time thinking that through and storyboarding that. The capability you now have is you can look at 1,000 simulations and pick out exactly the kind of shot you want to go with. Now, your creativity — combined with the automation benefit of seeing lots of options and testing different scenarios — will actually just get better. Something that would have taken months, or quarters, is now shrunk into a much shorter period. We imagined AI is gonna go replace those types of jobs. It won't, it will be another tool in their arsenal.

Share

Erase Yourself from the Web (sponsor)

Data brokers are making money off your personal information right now. They’ve bought your data — including SSNs, DOB, home addresses, and health information — and have sold it to the highest bidder.

Now it’s time to fight back. Incogni is a service that gets data brokers all over the world to delete your data. It contacts them, does the follow up work, and saves you the hundreds of hours it would otherwise take to get them to hit delete, and the potential chaos afterward.

After using Incogni, you’ll worry less about identity theft, health insurers raising your rates based on info from data brokers, robo calls, scammers taking out loans in your name, and all the other terrible things bad actors do with your personal data.

Check it out today and save 55% with the coupon code BIGTECH. Learn more here:

Learn More

What Else I’m Reading, Etc.

Sergei Brin is back at Google, up to four days per week [WSJ]

Google is testing AI that can write news stories [New York Times]

“Head of AI” is the hottest new job, but nobody knows what it means [Vox]

Threads usage is declining fast [Semafor]

Amazon’s pay by palm technology is coming to Whole Foods [CNBC]

Tech companies say the EU’s draft AI laws will force them to relocate [Reworked]

Study AI/ML to Future-Proof Your Career: Designed & taught by FAANG+ AI/ML Engineers. [Interview Kickstart] (Sponsor)

See a story you like? Tweet it with “tip @bigtechnology” for consideration in this section.

Number Of The Week

40,000+

The number of tickets reportedly sold by AMC to the double feature “Barbenheimer.” Moviegoers have been driven by a viral meme to watch the two wildly different features, Barbie and Opennheimer, in the same day.

Quote Of The Week

“At the end of the day I can’t wait to go home and turn off my phone and have a drink and get away from it all.”

- Disgraced Alameda Research ex-CEO Caroline Ellison, writing in Google docs as Sam Bankman-Fried’s empire headed toward ruin.

Advertise with Big Technology?

Advertising with Big Technology gets your product, service, or cause in front of the tech world’s top decision-makers. To reach 135,000+ plugged-in tech insiders, reply to this email or write alex.kantrowitz@gmail.com. We have availability starting in September.

This Week on Big Technology Podcast: The Declining Half-Life Of Social Media — With Eugene Wei

Eugene Wei is a tech analyst and product veteran, with time spent inside Meta, Amazon, and Hulu. He joins Big Technology Podcast for a discussion of social media's longevity, considering how the decay of mainstay platforms changes the incentives to participate. Tune in for a in-depth discussion of social media's longterm trajectory, examining the TikTok algorithm, Threads, Twitter under Musk, and the puzzling persistence of Facebook. In the second half, listen to an engaging lightening round, where Wei comments on the state of his former employers and his longtime friendship with Amazon CEO Andy Jassy.

You can listen on Apple, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts.

Thanks again for reading. Please share Big Technology if you like it!

Share

And hit that Like Button if you want more insights from top CEOs, coming directly to your inbox.

My book Always Day One digs into the tech giants’ inner workings, focusing on automation and culture. I’d be thrilled if you’d give it a read. You can find it here.

Questions? Email me by responding to this email, or by writing alex.kantrowitz@gmail.com

News tips? Find me on Signal at 516-695-8680

© 2023 Alex Kantrowitz
548 Market Street PMB 72296, San Francisco, CA 94104
Unsubscribe