As more than half the state's Methodist churches formally split from the United Methodist Church denomination over the past few years, the individual congregations were paying settlements to acquire their churches and infrastructure.
Some have paid as high as $4 million.
AL.com's Greg Garrison reports that Harvest Church of Dothan has been arguing in court that it already owns its own property.
There's a good bit at stake here: Harvest Church, now independent, is a large church that sits on 10 acres and has a worship center than seats 1,200.
Founding pastor Ralph Sigler has said the church has never had UMC on its sign and that some members weren't even aware of the affiliation. And when it bought its current property and built its current worship center, there was no "trust clause" to make the the Alabama-West Florida Conference of the UMC an owner of the property.
Harvest's efforts remained alive on Friday when the Alabama Supreme Court denied a UMC request to dismiss the lawsuit. A Houston County court denied the same earlier.
So now the case goes back to a lower court for a hearing.