Social media influencers: faking it even when they make it
TL:DR: A popular UK lifestyle and fashion magazine is in hot water after it introduced an artificial intelligence "fashion and lifestyle editor" on its social media page as a new member of its team.
I’ve always suspected that being an influencer is not a real job. The fact that SheerLuxe has just appointed a fake person to be an influencer has only strengthened my suspicions.
Stay with me now, because this is going to sound a little crazy, but I promise these are true events that are currently unfolding. SheerLuxe, a well-known UK lifestyle magazine, recently introduced an AI "fashion and lifestyle editor" named Reem on their social media channels. In images that accompany the post, editor-in-chief Charlotte Collins can be seen posing fashionably on a couch during a so-called “morning coffee and catch up meeting” with the new hire, an attractive young woman who appears to be of Middle Eastern descent. The part that is causing people on the internet all sorts of angst is that the new hire in the picture does not exist. Her likeness is 100% AI-generated. Further images divulge “what’s in Reem’s handbag”, “Reem’s desk setup” and “Reem’s go-to lunch”, accompanied by “selfies” snapped by Reem in and around the office.
You can see that original post (and read the seething comments) here.
So, just to clarify: SheerLuxe is using an AI-generated persona to make recommendations of real products to its readers, as if the persona were toting those products around in a handbag or displaying them on her desk. I’ve heard of suspension of disbelief before, but this is on another level entirely.
As you can imagine, this whole story has sparked a significant backlash from their nearly half a million Instagram followers. Critics argued that the move deprived human journalists of jobs and promoted unrealistic beauty standards. Some fans are expressing frustration over the unachievable beauty norms set by Reem's perfectly AI-generated body and visage. Others are questioning why SheerLuxe would rather invent a woman of colour than hire one.
In response, SheerLuxe issued an apology, stating their intent was to innovate but admitted they didn't explain it properly. They clarified that Reem's role was to provide fashion, beauty, and travel recommendations, and no human jobs were affected. Reem was created in collaboration with a Middle Eastern AI imagery creator, which influenced her appearance.
SheerLuxe's Instagram following saw a slight decline after the announcement, reflecting some fans' discontent. It’s not exactly an exodus of followers, but personally, I’ve read enough in that tirade of comments to think that we don’t have to be too worried about AI influencers just yet.