THE DAILY NEWSLETTER  - FRIDAY, OCTOBER 16, 2020

Media Winners & Losers

MEDIA WINNER:
Savannah Guthrie

NBC's Savannah Guthrie was in a tough spot heading into the town hall her network hosted with President Donald Trump Thursday evening. A last minute addition after the debate negotiations fell apart, the town hall drew scrutiny for being scheduled opposite the ABC forum with Democratic challenger Joe Biden

Add in the president's predilection for twisting facts and it's a challenge for any moderator. Oh, and Trump also tweeted insults at NBC and Guthrie a few hours before the town hall kicked off. 

Guthrie met the challenge head-on, peppering Trump with tough questions and openly challenging some of his more outlandish assertions. 

Among the topics Guthrie nailed: getting Trump to say he couldn't recall if he took a Covid test before the last debate, his defense of his retweet of an insane QAnon conspiracy theory that the bin Laden raid was faked, and his $400 million debt. And he ducked the chance to denounce QAnon once again.

Predictably, Trump surrogates and Fox News hosts (do we repeat ourselves?) complained that Guthrie was too harsh. 

But if the president of the United States shares a fake story that his predecessor schemed to fake the killing of a terrorist leader and murdered our own Navy SEALs, he should expect to get a question about it. 

Nothing Guthrie asked was inappropriate or irrelevant. She was in a tough, high pressure spot and held her on, asking questions to which the American people deserve answers. 

MEDIA LOSER:
Mercedes Schlapp

Trump campaign advisor Mercedes Schlapp, wife of CPAC head honcho Matt Schlapp, is becoming a regular contender for our daily Media Loser, and Thursday was a perfect illustration why. 

After Fox News' Greg Gutfeld tweeted a complaint that NBC's Guthrie was "badgering" Trump, Schlapp quoted him with her own comment, saying the ABC Biden forum “feels like I am watching an episode of Mister Rodgers' Neighborhood."

Besides the fact that Schlapp misspelled the last name of Fred Rogers, the late host of the beloved PBS children’s TV show Mister Rogers’ Neighborhood, the insinuation that invoking Rogers’ name was a valid way to criticize anyone struck many as completely absurd. 

As you probably can imagine, Twitter users had some jokes. The overwhelming reaction was that Rogers was a decent and universally liked figure, and comparing him to Biden was a great message for the Democratic nominee, and a terrible one for the Trump camp to highlight.

Now, the next morning after the dueling town halls, Schlapp's tweeted faux pas has continued to resonate, with several writers and political commentators framing the election as a contest between "Mr. Rogers vs. Crazy Uncle" -- a reference to Guthrie's comment to Trump that a president should use more prudence in what he tweets, and not act like "someone's crazy uncle."

The Biden campaign would be hard-pressed to create a better message for the final weeks of the campaign, and it was delivered to them courtesy of a top Trump campaign flack.  

“In many ways it was inevitable that there would be an outbreak."

CBS News White House correspondent Paula Reid spoke to Mediaite's The Interview podcast about reporting on the Trump administration as Covid-19 tore through the White House.

The A-Block

Dueling town halls

The competing presidential town halls were major news Thursday, with Trump on NBC and Biden on ABC. Check out more links for our coverage of Trump's contentious hour with our Media Winner Savannah Guthrie, above. 

The pandemic was a major topic, of course, and Biden slammed Trump's handling of it as a failure of the "presidential responsibility to lead." 

Biden also took a pointed question from a young Black voter, who asked him about his "you ain't Black" comments and why he deserved Black votes. Biden's answer was praised by many observers for its emotional emphasis and detailed policy discussions

Host George Stephanopoulos pressed Biden on the court packing question, and Biden again demurred -- but did say he would answer before Election Day and after the hearings for Supreme Court nominee Judge Amy Coney Barrett.

Bad news for the reality TV star president: Biden's town hall had significantly better ratings than his. CNN's Brian Stelter rubbed salt in the wound, noting that most of the industry expected the opposite. Love him or hate him, Trump is often entertaining TV. 

Biden Banks

Biden also has another reason to smile today: he's crushing it with the fundraising, bringing in $135 million more than Trump in September.

Hackery, not hacking

Yikes. C-SPAN's Steve Scully, who was supposed to moderate the second presidential debate, is in hot water after finally admitting that he wasn't hacked when he posted an odd tweet to Anthony Scaramucci. His admission is fueling the fire of critics of media bias and an embarrassment for Scully personally, C-SPAN, and the Commission on Presidential Debates

Trump took a victory lap on the news.

C-SPAN has suspended him. We'll also note that Mediaite reached out personally to Scully when the story originally broke, and he lied directly to our reporter as well. Lame, dude, very lame.

Turkey tragedy

Cancel Thanksgiving? Dr. Anthony Fauci said that might just be necessary this year as the pandemic rages on. See his comments here

Fake news!

Whoops. Trump tweeted a link from satirical site The Babylon Bee Friday morning, giving no indication he recognized their headline as a joke. 

Sasse gets sassy

Sen. Ben Sasse (R-OK) let loose in some harsh critiques of his party's president in a call with voters, absolutely torching Trump for being someone who "kisses dictators' butts" and has "flirted with white supremacists." Of course, Sasse launched these attacks after he survived his primary, having willingly accepted Trump's endorsement. 

Must See Clip

Only in Iowa

All politics is local, they say, and Sen. Joni Ernst (R-IA) learned a painful lesson on that topic on Thursday.

In her debate with her Democratic challenger Theresa Greenfield, Ernst totally whiffed on the price of soybeans. Bad enough, but Ernst's flop came immediately after Greenfield had nailed a similar question about the price of corn -- down to the penny. 

For an incumbent senator in a tough re-election battle (polls have shown Ernst trailing Greenfield by about five points for months), being out of touch with the state's vital agriculture industry was not a good look. 

The uniquely Iowan flavor of the question -- plus the "Midwestern passive-aggressiveness" of the fact-checking debate moderator -- made it a viral moment.

Pull over your ethanol-fueled vehicle and watch the video here.

Links We Like

Trump brought Fox News ‘facts’ to a confrontation with reality
- Phillip Bump, via Washington Post
Why 4,998 died in U.S. jails without getting their day in court
- via Reuters
He’s 32. He’s Joe Biden’s Press Secretary. And He Has Stage 4 Cancer. 
- via The Washingtonian

Efforts To Limit Ballot Drop-Off Boxes Are Cynical Electoral Gamesmanship
- via Reason

Mr. Rogers vs. Your Crazy Uncle
- Charlie Sykes, via The Bulwark
Twitter
Facebook
Visit Mediaite
Copyright © 2018 Mediaite LLC All rights reserved.

Write to us:  tips@mediaite.com

Problems with these e-mails? Update your preferences or unsubscribe from this list.