Both chambers of the Alabama Legislature Thursday passed bills that would shield in vitro fertilization clinics from legal actions, reports AL.com's Mike Cason.
The bills are nearly identical, so it's possible that early next week they'll be able to give final passage to one for the governor to sign. The House of Representatives passed its bill 94-6, with four Democrats and two Republicans voting against it. The Senate passed its bill 34-0.
This almost certainly isn't a permenent fix as lawmakers try to get IVF clinics reopened and operating after the state Supreme Court ruled that human embryos had the same rights as children according to the state Constitution. As a matter of fact, an early version of the bill on Thursday would have automatically repealed itself in June 2025.
That part was removed, but we can consider this a band-aid fix to keep and reopen the clinics.
One of the House sponsors, Decatur Republican Terri Collins, said she expects something more permanent to be carved out in the next year.
The debate we might expect includes the personhood issue (what point a fertilized egg becomes a person), whether the next step will be a state Constitutional amendment (the state high court ruling cited constitutional law), and how narrow or broad the clinics' immunity should be.
That is, will the immunity take away legal recourse from patients who suffer legitimate medical problems caused by IVF services?
Then again, maybe it wouldn't be a government law without unintended negative consequences.