This edition examines the implications of governance by Hay'at Tahrir al-Sham (HTS) in Damascus and

‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌
Powered by Axios HQ
Middle East Forum Banner

MEF Dispatch: Navigating the Post-Assad Middle East

By Ahnaf Kalam ● Dec 16, 2024

Smart Brevity® count: 6.5 mins...1747 words

This edition examines the implications of governance by Hay'at Tahrir al-Sham (HTS) in Damascus and offers insights into potential future Syrian leadership. We also discuss the power shifts following Assad's ouster, identifying beneficiaries like Turkey and Qatar, and the risks of new regional conflicts. This edition also explores the critical issue of unsecured chemical weapons in Syria, draws historical parallels to the strategic maneuvers of HTS leadership, and analyzes how these shifts might influence Iran's regional standing. Finally, we consider the political futures of leaders in Jordan and Azerbaijan, question their stability in the wake of Assad's fall, and provide a comprehensive look at the region's evolving dynamics.

ICYMI: The Houthis’ Rise from Local Gang to Global Menace with Michael Knights

Michael Knights Thumbnail

The Houthis of Yemen, once a minor Iran-backed militia, have emerged since Oct. 7 as a major force within Tehran’s “axis of resistance” due to their drone and missile attacks on ships in the Red Sea, their alliances with al-Shabaab and other jihadis, and their arms deals with Russia. This transformation raises urgent questions: What enabled it? How does the Houthis’ power affect regional dynamics? How have they managed to impede international trade for over a year? How best to counter this threat?

Michael Knights, a senior fellow at the Washington Institute for Near East Policy, specializes in the military and security issues. He has directed intelligence teams in Iraq, Libya, and Yemen, served as a defense journalist, and led analysis for security and oil companies. Mr. Knights holds a doctorate from King’s College London.

To watch the full podcast episode, click here.

What Al-Jolani’s Past Can Reveal About Syria’s Future

Islamist Rebel in Damascus
By: Jonathan Spyer

Al-Jolani's governance in Idleb offers insights into Syria's future under his leadership.

Why it matters: Understanding HTS's administration in Idleb is crucial as it may offer useful clues on how the group will govern Syria.

  • Authoritarian control: HTS enforced strict Islamic Sharia law, limiting freedoms and imposing harsh penalties.

  • No extremist excesses: Unlike Islamic State, HTS avoided the extreme measures of slavery and mass violence.

Governance style: HTS has historically maintained control through repression.

  • Religious influence: The highest authority, Abd al-Rahim Atoun, has espoused views aligning with jihadist principles.

  • Women's rights limited: Women have faced heavy restrictions in public and professional life.

Strategic foresight: Turkey’s support was pivotal for HTS's survival and eventual dominance.

  • Turkish enclave: The northwest served as a base for HTS, fostering its growth and eventual expansion.

What’s next: Al-Jolani's governance model might extend to other regions in Syria, challenging regional stability.

  • Military implications: Israel's efforts to limit HTS's military capabilities highlight regional security concerns.

To read the full article, click here.

Winners and Losers: Who Will Benefit in Assad Regime’s Fall?

Syrians in Damascus after Assad's fall
By: Jonathan Spyer

The fall of Assad's regime has triggered a significant reconfiguration of power dynamics in Syria.

Why it matters: Understanding who benefits from the regime's fall is crucial for anticipating future regional shifts.

  • HTS's new role: HTS's ascent to power underscores the resurgence of Sunni political Islam.

  • Iran's decline: Iran's influence in Syria has been substantially weakened, affecting its regional standing.

Who benefits: Turkey and Qatar have emerged as key players, having supported HTS's rise.

  • Turkey's strategic hold: By maintaining a foothold in northwest Syria, Turkey facilitated HTS's growth.

  • Qatar's financial backing: Long-standing financial ties with HTS have positioned Qatar as a significant influencer.

Challenges ahead: The new power structure faces potential internal conflicts and regional threats.

  • Internal divisions: The competition between HTS and the Syrian National Army (SNA) could lead to further instability.

  • Regional security concerns: Israel's strategic moves aim to contain potential threats from the new regime.

To read the full article, click here.

Syria’s Chemical Weapons Crisis Demands Action

Chemical barrels
By: Gregg Roman

The vulnerability of Assad's chemical weapons stockpiles presents a critical security challenge.

Why it matters: The unprotected arsenals pose a significant threat to regional stability and global security.

  • Proliferation risks: Unsecured chemical weapons could fall into the hands of terrorist groups or hostile states.

  • Regional instability: The potential misuse of these weapons threatens American forces and allies.

Immediate actions required: The U.S. faces urgent imperatives to secure these weapons.

  • Deploy specialized units: Quick deployment to identify and secure WMD sites is essential.

  • Strengthen containment: Expand military presence to monitor critical facilities and prevent transfers.

International collaboration: Cooperation with regional partners and allies is crucial.

  • Gulf allies' support: Saudi Arabia and the UAE's involvement underscores the need for robust American engagement.

  • Israeli vigilance: Mobilization in the Golan Heights highlights the urgency for securing chemical stockpiles.

America's strategic decisions now will shape Middle East security for decades. The time for decisive action is critical.

To read the full article, click here.

Syrian Rebel Leader Borrows a Page from Khomeini and Erdoğan’s Playbook

Syrians after the fall of Damascus
By: Michael Rubin

Jawlani's (Jolani) rise in Syria mirrors historical strategies by Khomeini and Erdoğan, raising concerns about future intentions.

Why it matters: The leadership style of Jawlani, head of Hay’at Tahrir al-Sham, suggests potential instability in the region.

  • Historical parallels: Like Khomeini and Erdoğan, Jawlani's moderate facade may mask deeper ideological goals.

  • Regional implications: The shift in power dynamics threatens fragile regional stability.

Strategic facade: Jawlani's public moderation contrasts with underlying radical ideologies.

  • Symbolic gestures: Declaring victory from the Umayyad Mosque signals continuity with historical Islamic power.

  • Western misjudgment: Historical precedents show how Islamist leaders have exploited diplomatic gullibility.

Potential threats: The consolidation of Sunni militant control in Syria could destabilize neighboring regions.

  • Risks for allies: Jordan and Saudi Arabia face an alarmingly heightened risk of Islamist influence and rebellion.

  • Western diplomacy challenge: Past missteps highlight the need for cautious engagement with emerging powers.

To read the full article, click here.

Assad’s Ouster Strikes a Blow to Iran, Though Maybe Not a Fatal One

Iran Syria flags
By: Shay Khatiri

Assad's removal has challenged Iran's influence in Syria, prompting a strategic reevaluation.

Why it matters: Iran's response to Assad's fall could reshape its future role in Syria and the region.

  • Change in tone: Iranian officials now speak more favorably of anti-Assad forces, testing potential alliances.

  • Seeking influence: Despite setbacks, Iran hopes to regain leverage in Syria, particularly if anti-Israel sentiments persist.

Strategic parallels: Iran's approach mirrors its past pragmatic shifts.

  • Taliban analogy: After near-conflict in 1998, Iran later pursued cooperation with the Taliban, showcasing flexibility.

  • Future alliances: Iran’s history suggests it could adapt similarly with new Syrian powers.

Regional dynamics: The broader geopolitical landscape influences Iran's strategy.

  • Turkey’s uncertainty: With Erdoğan's unpredictable policies, Iran sees potential openings for influence.

  • Long-term goals: Iran aims to maintain its status as an Islamic power, not just a Shi’ite force.

Iran's tactical maneuvering post-Assad highlights its enduring ambition to maintain influence in the Middle East.

To read the full article, click here.

Support MEF: Help Defend Western Values

EOY CTA

The time to act is now. Critical opportunities lie before us to shape policy, expose Islamist propaganda and strengthen our Middle East allies on the front lines of conflict.

Your tax-deductible gift powers our mission to uncover extremist networks, transform public debate, and advance strategic policies through key partnerships. As global threats intensify, your support ensures we continue delivering measurable results.

Will you help us protect the democratic principles that define our civilization?

Click here to make a tax-deductible gift to the Middle East Forum.

Another Revolution Gets Hijacked in the Middle East

Anti-Assad Syrians
By: Kamal Chomani

The fall of Assad highlights ongoing challenges in achieving true democratic change in the Middle East.

Why it matters: The cycle of uprisings and elite control threatens the democratic dreams of millions in the region.

  • Hijacked revolutions: Authoritarian regimes and external powers continue to suppress genuine democratic movements.

  • Regional dynamics: The rise of groups like Hay’at Tahrir al-Sham reflects a shift from one form of authoritarianism to another.

Challenges ahead: True democracy in Syria remains elusive amid external influences.

  • External meddling: Countries like Turkey shape Syria's future, often sidelining local aspirations.

  • Democratic facade: Leaders claim democratic intentions while consolidating power.

Path forward: Protecting democratic experiments is crucial for regional stability.

  • Support for the SDF: The success of Kurdish-led forces offers a model for democratic governance.

  • International responsibility: Global actors must ensure that Syrian aspirations lead to genuine democracy rather than renewed authoritarianism.

To read the full article, click here.

Is Jordan’s King Abdullah II a ‘Dead Man Walking’?

King Jordan II
By: Michael Rubin

King Abdullah II faces mounting challenges as regional dynamics shift following Assad's fall.

Why it matters: Jordan's stability is crucial for regional security, but internal and external pressures are rising.

  • Regional ripple effect: The fall of Assad may inspire instability in Jordan, with potential impacts on regional alliances.

  • Internal discontent: Economic growth hasn't alleviated public dissatisfaction with the monarchy's lifestyle and governance.

Geopolitical pressures: External influences threaten to reshape Jordan's political landscape.

  • Turkish influence: Turkey's support for Syria's Sunni Islamists could embolden groups like Hamas, posing a direct threat to Jordan.

  • Demographic vulnerabilities: With a significant Palestinian population, Jordan remains susceptible to Islamist ideologies.

Strategic implications: Jordan's position as a moderate ally is at risk.

  • Regional security cornerstone: The U.S. and Israel rely on Jordan for stability; its fall could embolden extremists and destabilize borders.

  • International stakes: Abdullah's survival is key to preventing a power vacuum that could shift regional dynamics unfavorably.

To read the full article, click here.

Could Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev Collapse Like Assad?

Ilham Aliyev
By: Michael Rubin

Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev's reign faces potential challenges similar to those that led to Assad's downfall.

Why it matters: The fall of Assad serves as a cautionary tale for authoritarian leaders like Aliyev.

  • Economic disparity: Despite Azerbaijan's oil wealth, many citizens live in poverty, echoing the economic grievances in Syria.

  • Corruption concerns: The Aliyev family's opulence contrasts sharply with the hardships faced by ordinary Azerbaijanis.

Potential vulnerabilities: Aliyev's grip on power may be more tenuous than it appears.

  • Public discontent: Like Assad, Aliyev's rule is marred by nepotism and corruption, which could fuel unrest.

  • Regional dynamics: Russia's preoccupation with Ukraine suggests limited support for Aliyev in a crisis.

Lessons from history: Dictators who ignore public sentiment risk sudden upheavals.

  • External perceptions: Aliyev's popularity abroad does not translate to domestic stability.

  • Historical parallels: Past uprisings in the region highlight the risks of ignoring socio-economic disparities.

Aliyev's future hinges on addressing internal grievances and fostering genuine public support.

To read the full article, click here.

From the Houthis' disruptive influence in the Persian Gulf to the reshaping of power and securing of chemical weapons in Syria post-Assad, each of these developments in the region demonstrates that the challenges are manifold. As these narratives unfold, they stress the need for vigilant analysis and strategic foresight to navigate the future of the region.

Sincerely,
Ahnaf Kalam
Digital Media Specialist
Middle East Forum

Was this edition useful?

Thumbs upThumbs down

Leave feedback

Your responses are anonymous

MEF, an activist think tank, deals with the Middle East, Islamism, U.S. foreign policy, and related topics, urging bold measures to protect Americans and their allies. Pursuing its goals via intellectual and operational means, the Forum recurrently has policy ideas adopted by the U.S. government.

Copyright © 2024 Middle East Forum, All rights reserved.

Our mailing address is:

Middle East Forum
1650 Market Street, Suite 3600
Philadelphia, PA 19103

Powered by

This edition is powered by Axios HQ.

This email was sent by Middle East Forum via Axios HQ