From exploding pagers to diplomatic tightropes, the Middle East remains a powder keg of tactical vic

‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌
Powered by Axios HQ
Middle East Forum Banner

Pager Warfare and Shifting Frontlines: Israel, Hezbollah, and a Region in Turmoil

By Ahnaf Kalam ● Sep 21, 2024

Smart Brevity® count: 5 mins...1282 words

From exploding pagers to diplomatic tightropes, the Middle East remains a powder keg of tactical victories and strategic stalemates. This briefing dissects Israel's covert operations against Hezbollah, debates the legality of unconventional warfare, and examines the ripple effects across the region - from Iran's propaganda machine to Sudan's overlooked tragedy.

As the Abraham Accords face their toughest test yet, we explore how age-old conflicts are being reshaped by modern tactics and shifting alliances.

Exploding Pagers Signal Dilemmas for Both Hezbollah and Israel

Exploding pagers
By Jonathan Spyer

The killing of 11 Hezbollah members due to exploding pagers marks a tactical win for Israel, highlighting the deep infiltration of Hezbollah.

Why it matters: This incident underscores Hezbollah’s vulnerabilities and boosts Israeli confidence in their security capabilities, but it doesn’t change the ongoing conflict dynamics on Israel’s northern border.

  • Despite this tactical success, Israel faces significant strategic challenges.

  • The displacement of 60,000 Israelis from the border area remains a pressing issue.

The big picture: Israel consistently demonstrates superior tactical capabilities against Hezbollah, yet this hasn’t enabled them to decisively alter the strategic picture.

  • Hezbollah’s daily missile and drone attacks have led to the evacuation of residents along the Israel-Lebanese border.

  • This situation is unprecedented in Israel’s history and has ominous implications for regional stability.

What’s next: Israel faces the dilemma of whether to launch a ground operation to push Hezbollah back, a move complicated by exhausted ground forces and the need for US resupply.

  • A ground maneuver could push Hezbollah 7-10 kilometers north but would likely result in heavy attrition.

  • Holding such an area post-operation would present additional challenges, including the risk of a prolonged counter-insurgency.

Yes, but: Hezbollah must decide how to retaliate without provoking an all-out war, balancing the need to satisfy their supporters and patrons with the desire to avoid escalation.

  • Past attempts at retaliation have been minor and often claimed fictional successes to avoid broader conflict.

  • The new vulnerabilities exposed may require a more determined response, increasing the risk of escalation.

Was ‘Operation Below the Belt’ Legal? Absolutely

Another exploding pager
By Elizabeth Samson

The synchronized explosions of Hezbollah’s devices were precise and disrupted internal communications, but faced international criticism for allegedly violating international law.

Why it matters: The attack followed protocols defined by the United Nations Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons (CCW), targeting devices used exclusively by Hezbollah.

  • This incident underscores the legal complexities of military actions under international law.

The big picture: Despite condemnation, Israel’s operation was within the legal framework of the CCW, distinguishing between military and civilian targets.

  • The operation aimed to disrupt Hezbollah’s communications and morale.

Yes, but: Critics argue the attack risked civilian casualties, reflecting the ongoing debate over international humanitarian law in asymmetric warfare.

Blinded Hezbollah Terrorists Shouldn’t Expect Sympathy in Iran

Hizballah soldiers
By Michael Rubin

The Iranian government is using cheap theatrics to garner sympathy for Hezbollah terrorists blinded by exploding pagers, but Iranians see through the propaganda.

Why it matters: The systematic use of blinding as a punishment by the Iranian regime has eroded its legitimacy, and Iranians have little sympathy for Hezbollah’s plight.

  • Hezbollah members are viewed as enforcers of the regime’s brutal tactics.

  • The regime’s brutality during protests has led to widespread resentment.

The big picture: Iran’s use of Hezbollah to suppress protests and the regime’s reliance on violence highlight the deep-rooted issues within the Islamic Republic.

  • Iranians recognize Hezbollah as cogs in the regime’s repressive machine.

  • The regime’s propaganda fails to resonate with the Iranian public.

What’s next: As the Iranian regime continues to lose legitimacy, its reliance on Hezbollah and other proxies may increase, but sympathy for these groups will remain limited.

  • The West should be wary of Iranian propaganda and understand the true dynamics within Iran.

  • The international community’s focus should remain on the regime’s human rights abuses.

While Still in Gaza, Israel Has No Good Options in Lebanon. But It May Invade Anyway

Artillery in Khiam
By Lazar Berman

The IDF and the home front are weary, and a military offensive against Hezbollah won’t defeat the terror organization. The success of the pager operation could offer a way out.

Why it matters: Israel’s continued military actions could lead to significant regional implications, with potential consequences for both Gaza and Lebanon.

  • The IDF is stretched thin, impacting its ability to achieve decisive victories.

  • The success of the pager operation highlights Israel’s intelligence capabilities.

The big picture: Israel faces several strategic options in Lebanon, each with significant risks and challenges.

  • Aerial offensives or ground operations could lead to prolonged conflict and civilian casualties.

  • Buffer zones have historically been ineffective and may require continuous military presence.

What’s next: Israel must balance its objectives in Gaza with potential escalations in Lebanon, deciding whether to pursue a ground operation against Hezbollah.

  • Diplomatic strategies may be necessary to avoid a full-scale war.

  • The pager operation’s success could deter Hezbollah and open avenues for negotiation.

Four Years On, Abraham Accords Are Strained by Gaza War — But Prove Resilient

Signing of the Abraham Accords
By Lazar Berman

The visibility of ties with Bahrain, Morocco, and the UAE has changed since Hamas’s attacks on October 7, but Israel’s newest Arab partners remain committed to a strategic choice.

Why it matters: Despite the strain from the ongoing conflict, the Abraham Accords continue to hold, showing the resilience of Israel’s relationships with the Arab world.

  • The accords have survived multiple challenges, including war, COVID-19, and political changes.

  • Bilateral trade with Bahrain, UAE, and Morocco has significantly increased.

The big picture: While there have been tensions and reduced visibility of ties, the strategic decision to normalize relations remains strong.

  • The UAE, Bahrain, and Morocco continue to engage diplomatically and economically with Israel.

  • Despite public criticism, trade and cooperation behind the scenes persist.

What’s next: Israel aims to expand the circle of peace, with hopes of including more countries in the region.

  • The success of the Abraham Accords may pave the way for normalization with Saudi Arabia and other nations.

  • Long-term peace and integration in the Middle East remain key objectives.

The World Turns a Blind Eye to Sudan

Sudanese flag with blood and soldiers
By Jonathan Spyer

The international community seems indifferent to Sudan’s 15-month war that has killed thousands and displaced even more.

Why it matters: The conflict between the Sudanese Armed Forces (SAF) and Rapid Support Forces (RSF) has led to massive displacement and a looming famine, with 25 million people needing humanitarian assistance.

  • The war has caused up to 150,000 deaths and displaced 10.2 million people.

  • Aid groups warn of a historic starvation crisis.

The big picture: Sudan’s conflict fits the pattern of Middle Eastern wars leading to state collapse and de facto partition, with rival powers sponsoring local factions.

  • The SAF and RSF emerged from the regime of Omar al-Bashir, cooperating to topple him but now fighting each other.

  • The RSF controls much of the west, while the SAF holds the east, including Port Sudan.

Yes, but: International powers have taken sides, with Egypt and Saudi Arabia backing the SAF, and the UAE supporting the RSF, each seeking strategic advantages.

  • Iran is aiding the SAF with drones, aiming for influence in the Red Sea.

  • The UAE sees economic benefits in supporting the RSF, controlling gold mines and planning new ports.

The Middle East's geopolitical chessboard continues to evolve at a dizzying pace. While Israel's pager operation against Hezbollah showcases its tactical prowess, the broader strategic picture remains murky. The Abraham Accords' resilience in the face of Gaza's turmoil offers a glimmer of hope, even as Sudan's devastating war fades from global attention.

As regional powers jockey for position and the rules of engagement blur, the path to lasting stability remains as elusive as ever. The coming months will likely determine whether these tactical maneuvers can translate into meaningful strategic gains or if the region is destined for further cycles of conflict.

Stay tuned for further developments.

Sincerely,

Ahnaf Kalam
Digital Media Specialist
Middle East Forum

Feedback

Please share your thoughts on this edition.

Was this edition useful?

Thumbs upThumbs down

Your responses are anonymous

MEF, an activist think tank, deals with the Middle East, Islamism, U.S. foreign policy, and related topics, urging bold measures to protect Americans and their allies. Pursuing its goals via intellectual and operational means, the Forum recurrently has policy ideas adopted by the U.S. government.

Copyright © 2024 Middle East Forum, All rights reserved.

Our mailing address is:

Middle East Forum
1650 Market Street, Suite 3600
Philadelphia, PA 19103

Powered by

This edition is powered by Axios HQ.

This email was sent by Middle East Forum via Axios HQ