Nieman Lab: The Daily Digest

No need to shoot The Messenger: Its muddled ideas are doing the job

The new site from the former owner of The Hill — backed by $50 million — feels like a remnant of an earlier age. By Joshua Benton.
What We’re Reading
Variety / Tatiana Siegel
Inside Tucker Carlson’s battle to trade his $20 million Fox News salary for a Twitter show →
“On April 26, Carlson spoke by phone with one of Fox Corp.’s eight board members, who told the host that his recent benching was a condition of Fox News’ settlement with Dominion Voting Systems, according to multiple sources with knowledge of the conversation.”
Platformer / Casey Newton
Why you can’t trust Twitter’s encrypted DMs →
“One reason to care about how secure your nominally encrypted messages are is that, when pressed, tech platforms sometimes share encryption keys with the government.”
The Verge / Mia Sato
CNET staff are unionizing, citing editorial independence and use of AI tools →
“The bargaining unit will include around 100 staffers ranging from reporters and editors to video production teams. A ‘solid and dedicated majority’ of unit members have signed union cards, and workers are asking Red Ventures, the private equity-backed marketing firm that owns CNET, to voluntarily recognize the union.”
Columbia Journalism Review / Jon Allsop
What a national-security regulator could mean for media deals →
“TikTok is not what used to be termed a news-media company. But it is a company that disseminates news, and that news organizations use to reach consumers. And the recent reporting on Forbes — which, compared to the furor around TikTok, has flown somewhat under the radar — raised questions for me about the evolving role of CFIUS and how it might apply to more traditional news-media takeovers going forward.”
Column / Adam Johnson
As TV writers strike, U.S. media is echoing film studio executives’ “AI writer” hype →
“Feeding writers ‘AI’-generated scripts that are filled with bloodless, generic cliches, that can’t use metaphor, lack scene context, nuance, or fidelity to structure, that have no originality or humor or spark, and asking them to rewrite said scripts simply adds superfluous steps to the process. There’s another word for rewriting: it’s called ‘writing.'”
Rest of World / Andrew Deck
TikTok creators are using ChatGPT and Midjourney to rewrite history →
“The subset of creators is playing into a decolonial curiosity with its content — one that seems to ask, what if Western imperial nations never came to power?”
Interview Magazine / Taylore Scarabelli
Style and culture journalist Robin Givhan on the state of fashion criticism in 2023 →
“I think sometimes people confuse the idea of criticism with having an opinion. I think it’s great that lots of people are drawn to fashion and have an opinion, and can put that opinion out there for public consumption. But I don’t think that that necessarily means that they’re a critic or that what they’re doing is criticism.”
Talking Biz News / Chris Roush
The Wall Street Journal will stop using courtesy titles in its news stories →
“Dropping courtesy titles is more in line with the way people communicate their identities. It puts everyone on a more-equal footing.”
Rest of World / Nadia Nooreyezdan
India’s religious AI chatbots are speaking in the voice of god – and condoning violence →
“At least five GitaGPTs have sprung up between January and March this year, with more on the way. Experts have warned that chatbots being allowed to play god might have unintended, and dangerous, consequences.”
The New Republic / Prem Thakker
CNN’s Trump town hall audience was told “please do not boo” →
“If CNN really wanted to know what Republican voters think of Trump, why did it set rules like this?”
Dow Jones
Dow Jones and Columbia Journalism School launch HBCU Media Collective →
The inaugural cohort includes nine emerging journalists from Dillard University, Howard University, Morehouse College, Morgan State University, Spelman College, and Texas Southern University. Students will embed alongside financial journalists at The Wall Street Journal, Barron’s, and MarketWatch.