View email online
 
 
     
   
     
   
     
  Mar 11, 2024  
     
 
Alan Young
 
Alan Young
Deputy Editor
The Scotsman, along with most other newspapers across the country, carried a picture of a smiling Princess of Wales and her children on our front page today. 
 
The first image of the Princess since she underwent surgery, it was naturally lapped up after it was released by Kensington Palace yesterday. But if the strategy was to combat social media speculation about Kate's absence in public, it has spectacularly backfired. 
 
First, the picture was withdrawn with a “Kill” notice by international picture agencies last night because of suspicions it had been "manipulated". Inconsistencies had been noted in several parts of the picture, from Charlotte's disappearing sleeve to the pattern on Louis' jumper.
 
The Press Association followed suit on Monday morning because they said they had received no explanation from the Palace. 
 
Then came the statement from the Princess of Wales amid mounting pressure
 

“Like many amateur photographers, I do occasionally experiment with editing.
“I wanted to express my apologies for any confusion the family photograph we shared yesterday caused.

“I hope everyone celebrating had a very happy Mother’s Day. C.” 
 
Why does this all matter? After all who hasn't edited their own family pictures before posting on social media to ensure they are presented in the best possible light?
 
The answer taps into a story of our time. With ever-more powerful AI technology, photos can now be manipulated convincingly at the touch of a smartphone screen. How do we know what to trust as genuine and dismiss what has been digitally created? 
 
In journalism, the source is all important, and the Royal family was pretty close to the most trusted source of all. 
 
We hope the embarrassment of this episode will ensure it becomes so again. 
 
Martyn McLaughlin gets into it with analysis available to subscribers at scotsman.com here
 
Have a great evening 
 
Alan
 
 
 
     
 
Analysis: Kensington Palace must throw open the curtains after Princess of Wales photo controversy
 
Analysis: Kensington Palace must throw open the curtains after Princess of Wales photo controversy
 
Read more +
 
Flooding
 
Pass or fail? Jenny Gilruth's report card for her first year as Scottish education secretary
 
Read more +
 
     
 
Edinburgh Festival Fringe: New multi-million pound headquarters project set to get green light
 
Edinburgh Festival Fringe: New multi-million pound headquarters project set to get green light
 
Read more +
 
Flooding
 
SNP minister Angus Robertson claims UK Cabinet members ‘not interested’ in good relations and often skip meetings
 
Read more +
 
     
  Scotland's habit of letting leads slip has fatally undermined their Six Nations campaign  
     
  Scotland's habit of letting leads slip has fatally undermined their Six Nations campaign  
     
  Read more +  
     
     
 
 
     
     
     
   
   
   
 
You have received this email as you have an opted in to exclusive Insider communications from The Scotsman.
Log in or create an account to manage your newsletter preferences.
 
 
You can also change the types of emails you receive from us or completely stop all emails.
 
 

National World Publishing Ltd
Published by National World Publishing Ltd

Registered in England and Wales (11499982). E3, Joseph's Well, Hanover Walk, Leeds, England, LS3 1AB, United Kingdom.
We will process your personal data in accordance with our Privacy notice.