Before the terror of Dallas, I assumed we would be using this space to talk about the politics of police brutality, of racial disparity in America and of the Black Lives Matter movement -- issues that have seized the nation this week after the killings of two black men in Minnesota and Louisiana by two white …
 
The 5-Minute Fix
Keeping up with politics is easy now
 
 

Before the terror of Dallas, I assumed we would be using this space to talk about the politics of police brutality, of racial disparity in America and of the Black Lives Matter movement -- issues that have seized the nation this week after the killings of two black men in Minnesota and Louisiana by two white police officers.

We still will, but that discussion gets much more complicated after sniper fire (and there may have been only one shooter) killed five police officers and injured seven at a peaceful protest in Dallas.

Our paper's chief political correspondent, Dan Balz, recently put into words what many of us are feeling right now after all this bloodshed -- confusion:

"The week of gunfire and fallen bodies and videos too graphic to absorb but impossible not to watch has produced a whiplash of emotions and reactions. Whether they add up to anything constructive or simply add to the feeling of a country that is fractured and breaking apart is another matter — but one of genuine urgency."

We'll come back to that question in a minute. But first, in assessing the immediate political aftermath of this week, I have a takeaway of my own to add: Racial politics does not always fall into neat categories, but it is still quite divisive.

Let's start with Donald Trump, who said this:

social_card [Fri Jul 08 2016 15-50-56 GMT-0400 (Eastern Daylight Time)]

Maybe it's just us, but the passage above from Trump's decidedly toned-down statement (at least, compared to the bluster of his reaction to Orlando) could be interpreted as sympathizing with the protesters of police violence. Which is notable since it's a group that tends to be concentrated on the left of the political spectrum.

The Fix's Aaron Blake explains: "'Senseless' is a very loaded word in what is a very heated political debate over police violence. And it's not loaded in the political direction in which Trump generally veers."

We noticed a similar dynamic with Newt Gingrich. The former House speaker said to be on Trump's short list for vice president said this in a Facebook Live chat with CNN on Friday:

social_card [Fri Jul 08 2016 15-52-58 GMT-0400 (Eastern Daylight Time)]

Gingrich went on: "If you are a normal white American, the truth is you don’t understand being black in America, and you instinctively under-estimate the level of discrimination and the level of additional risk."

Again, writes Blake, those are sentiments you expect to hear from the political left -- not from the potential No. 1 and No. 2 Repubilcan in America.

Maybe there is some room in our political arena for an actual conversation about race and policing in this country.

Maybe. Americans are split on a lot of thorny questions from this week

Marques Armstrong chants in support of Philando Castile, who was fatally shot by Minneapolis area police during a traffic stop on Wednesday, at a "Black Lives Matter" demonstration, in front of the Governor's Mansion in St. Paul, Minnesota, U.S., July 7, 2016. REUTERS/Eric Miller

Marques Armstrong chants in support of Philando Castile, who was fatally shot by Minneapolis area police during a traffic stop on Wednesday, at a "Black Lives Matter" demonstration, in front of the Governor's Mansion in St. Paul, Minnesota. (REUTERS/Eric Miller)

Let's briefly run down some stats.

On the issue of equality in our criminal justice system: About half of white Americans believe black people and other minorities receive equal treatment in the criminal justice system, according to the Public Religion Research Institute.

And perhaps more interestingly, a Washington Post-ABC poll in December 2014 showed eight in 10 white Republican believed police treat black and white people equally.

I'll be curious to see how the numbers change after this week. But for now, this is our starting point:

ADVERTISEMENT
 
Washington Post, December 2014 survey

Washington Post, December 2014 survey

On the Black Lives Matter movement: In general, support for the movement tends to be divided between race and politics.

(Philip Bump / The Washington Post)

(Philip Bump / The Washington Post)

Dallas, the blame game

A Dallas Area Rapid Transit police officer receives comfort at the Baylor University Hospital emergency room entrance Thursday, July 7, 2016, in Dallas. Police say one rapid-transit officer has been killed and three injured when gunfire erupted during a protest in downtown Dallas over recent fatal shootings by police in Louisiana and Minnesota. (Ting Shen/The Dallas Morning News via AP)

A Dallas Area Rapid Transit police officer receives comfort at the Baylor University Hospital emergency room entrance Thursday. (Ting Shen/The Dallas Morning News via AP)

Perhaps our very different lenses for looking at racial injustice and police brutality in America help explain why practically every politician is blaming a different group or person for what went so terribly wrong in America this week. Or at least it feels that way:

Texas Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick blamed Black Lives Matter in an interview: "I do blame people on social media with their hatred towards police ... I do blame former Black Lives Matter protests."

Corey A. Stewart, a Republican candidate in the 2017 race for Virginia governor and Trump's campaign chair in the state, blamed Hillary Clinton: "Liberal politicians who label police as racists," he wrote on Facebook, " ... are to blame for essentially encouraging the murder of these police officers tonight."

Libertarian candidate for president Gary Johnson, blamed the drug war: "The root is the war on drugs, I believe," Johnson told Politico. "Police knocking down doors, shooting first. … That’s the common thread."

And Rep. Roger Williams (R), whose congressional district runs from Fort Worth to Austin, blamed basically everyone: "[The] spread of misinformation and constant instigation by prominent leaders, including our president, have contributed to the modern day hostility we are witnessing between the police and those they serve."

Some historical context

Our nation has been through violent summers before, Balz notes. In 1967 there were riots in Newark and Detroit. The following spring and summer, Martin Luther King, Jr. and Robert F. Kennedy were killed. This week's violence begs reflection, and perhaps a comparison.

Balz: "A year after the 1967 riots, the Kerner Commission, appointed by then-President Lyndon B. Johnson, produced a report whose most remembered words were: 'Our nation is moving toward two societies, one black, one white — separate but unequal,'" he writes. "What would a similar commission say about the country today, nearly a half-century later? Perhaps only to add that the country is also divided red and blue."

That data might support that, writes The Fix's Philip Bump, who dug into it and found: "A Republican Party that's mostly white. A black population that's mostly Democratic."

More disconcertingly, Bump writes, more than 4-in-10 Republicans and Democrats view members of the opposite party as "a threat to the nation's well-being."

(Philip Bump / The Washington Post)

(Philip Bump / The Washington Post)

(Philip Bump / The Washington Post)

(Philip Bump / The Washington Post)

That's it for Friday. Thanks for reading, everyone, and we have much more below.

Save

 
If you’re a new 5-Minute Fix reader, sign up here. If you’re a regular, forward this to anyone you think wants to sounds like they know what they’re talking about in 2016. And don’t forget to follow me on Twitter, which is where I take suggestions on gifs!

Thumb not tired yet // trying to avoid someone? Read these awesome pieces:
Why the Dallas police had explosives, and how those explosives were fatal
A bomb expert explains what might be in the department's arsenal.
 
The complicated racial history of the former GOP congressman who warned Obama to ‘watch out’ after Dallas shootings
Joe Walsh said Obama won election because he was a "black man who was articulate."
 
Why so many critics of President Obama insist that he hates police officers
It all began with the famous "beer summit" in 2009.
 
The media debate over the Dallas ‘civil war’ comparison
The New York Post's provocative cover leads the way.
 
 
The irony at the heart of the Dallas police deaths after a Black Lives Matter march
The city has implemented the sorts of reforms protesters seek.
 
The state where targeting a police officer is a hate crime
On Capitol Hill and in most statehouses, legislation to expand punishment for killing police has stalled.
 
Why President Obama went right to gun control after five police officers were killed in Dallas
This is a president increasingly unconcerned about accusations that he is "politicizing" tragedies.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
 
Recommended for you
 
Fact Checker
Count the pinocchios. A weekly review of what's true, false or in-between.
Sign Up »
 
     
 
©2016 The Washington Post, 1301 K St NW, Washington DC 20071