The Economic Data Can't Possibly Be Accurate. Here Is Proof.

To investors,

I hope each of you had a great weekend. At the end of last week, I saw a chart that really confused me. It showed the difference between the CPI Rent Index and the Zillow Rent Index.

These numbers show that Zillow is estimating rents are increasing about 5.5% to 6% annually right now. The CPI Rent Index is showing just under 2% rent growth.

The confusing part of this was that the two metrics, which are supposed to be measuring the exact same thing, are apparently coming in at such different numbers. The Zillow Rent Index is almost 300% higher than the CPI Rent Index. But they weren’t the only ones.

The Apartment Guide rent report published on August 31, 2021 also showed numbers significantly higher than the CPI Rent Index.

The lowest rental increase for the national average was more than 2x the CPI Rent Index number. How could this be?

Well, I started to dig deeper into the data and what I found was honestly shocking. It all starts with the data sets that are being used by the various reports. First, the CPI Rent Index uses the following definition for rent in the CPI:

“The rent estimates used in the CPI are contract rents. They are the payment for all services provided by the landlord to the tenant in exchange for rent. For example, if the landlord provides electricity or other utilities, these would be part of the contract rent. The CPI item expenditure weights also include the full contract rent payment. Rents are calculated as the amounts the tenants pay their landlords, plus any rent reductions tenants receive for performing services on behalf of the landlord, plus any subsidy payment paid to the landlord. Reductions for any other reason are not considered part of the rent.”

So how exactly do they do select which units and/or tenants or landlords to survey? The government uses the 1990 Census data obviously. No, seriously. I had to read this about 50 times before I actually believed it. Here is the exact explanation:

“Using data from the 1990 Decennial Census of Population and Housing, the CPI defined small geographic areas, called segments, within each of the 87 CPI pricing areas. Segments are one or more Census blocks. The Census provided the numbers of renter and owner housing units in each segment and the average rent of the renter units in each segment; BLS estimated the average implicit rent of the owner units in the segment, enabling the CPI to calculate the total spending (rent plus implicit rent) for each segment. The CPI selected a sample of segments in each pricing area using stratified sampling in proportion to total shelter value. CPI agents visited the segments and selected a small number (usually 5) of renter-occupied housing units in each one to represent the segment. For segments that contain largely owner occupied housing units, rental units from segments close to the selected segment to help represent the segment.”

Ok, that seems crazy but maybe we are just overreacting. How many units are included in the national rent index? Must be millions, right? Nope. It is only 32,000 total units. Here is the explanation:

“The CPI Housing survey has about 32,000 renter-occupied housing units. In the 1990 Census, which was the sampling frame for the primary CPI Housing survey, there were about 28.6 million renter-occupied units and 41.3 million owner occupied housing units in the urban United States.”

This is starting to look absolutely ridiculous. But it is about to get even better. If you’re going to report a monthly change in the national rent average, you’re obviously going to survey the units on a monthly basis, right? Nope. The government only surveys the units every 6 months.

“Because rents change rather infrequently, the CPI program collects rent data from each sampled unit every six months. (Price collection is monthly or bimonthly for most other CPI items.) Collecting rent data less frequently allows a much larger sample. The CPI divides each area’s rent sample into six sub-samples called panels. The rents for panel 1 are collected in January and July; panel 2, in February and August, etc.”

Now the government does their best to account for the lack of monthly surveying…by increasing rents by one dollar (lol). I wish that I was making this up. But here is the information directly from the BLS’ fact sheet.

“In addition the CPI adjusts the rent for the effect of aging of the rental units over time. The Housing sample collects the rents from the same housing units every six months. Consequently, each time the CPI observes the rent of a sample unit it is six months older. To account for this aging, an age-bias factor is applied to the current rent; this raises the rent slightly because the older unit is slightly less desirable. For example, a unit with a rent of $900 might have the rent adjusted to $901.”

Alright, in case you weren’t paying attention, here is what we have making up the CPI Rent Index — Approximately 32,000 units across the US that were selected based on the 1990 census data and are each surveyed only twice a year. Sounds like a disaster.

Now what about the Zillow Rent Index? Here is how they describe their methodology:

“Every month, a Rent Zestimate is created for more than 100 million U.S. housing units for which Zillow has sufficient data. The sources of this data include public records (property taxes, transactions), real estate listings and user-generated data. Real estate listing data comes from local Multiple Listings Services and/or direct feeds to Zillow from real estate brokers. User-generated data includes rental listings and for-sale listings posted directly on Zillow, and user corrections to incorrect and/or out-of-date data from listings and public records. Properties enter and leave this ‘universe’ due to many reasons, the most important of which are discussed below.

As the Zillow rental business and our data sources expand, we may become aware of more individual units within a building and add them to our “rental universe.” Periodically, these are retroactively given Rent Zestimate histories using attributes of the unit and the Rent Zestimate model. We take advantage of these retroactive histories in the first calculation of the Zillow Rent Index using our updated methodology.”

Zillow then describes how they don’t take a small sample size of homes within a region, but rather they use every home or unit.

“To create the index, we consider every home within a given region for which we have a Rental Zestimate for that period, then reweight and aggregate those estimates.”

So the government is using 32,000 units that they survey every 6 months and Zillow is using 100 million units that they evaluate every month. You can determine which of these two methodologies you believe are more likely to be accurate :)

This exercise was only done for the rent index, but you can replicate it for pretty much every single CPI number that is presented. The data is bad. The methodology is antiquated. The government is living in the past and refuses to use modern technologies and platforms to capture more accurate data.

It is impossible to make good decisions when you are using bad data. Everything from your understanding of the problems to your belief in the intended outcomes is skewed. This is a very real problem that is provable today.

The Federal Reserve, Treasury, and various politicians are making monetary and fiscal policy decisions on data that is telling them CPI inflation is 5.3%, core inflation is 4%, and the annual change of the rent index is sub 2%. Alternative data sources, which use more robust methodologies and are based on larger data sets, have these numbers at 50% to 300% higher depending on the metric.

Maybe the alternative data sets are accurate. Or maybe they are overestimating to some degree. But what is clear here is that the CPI Rent Index can’t possibly produce an accurate monthly number if they aren’t even surveying the housing units on a monthly basis. Therein lies the problem. Bad data gets you bad decisions. And bad decisions have severe consequences when you are dealing with monetary and fiscal decisions that end up making the rich richer and the poor poorer.

Someone stop the madness. Make it all make sense. Because right now none of this adds up. Hope each of you has a great start to your week. I’ll talk to everyone tomorrow.

-Pomp

SPONSORED: Polymarket is the world’s leading information markets platform where you can trade on a variety of markets – politics, current events, and more – all on the blockchain.

Take, for example, this market on whether the floor price of CryptoPunks will
be above 100 ETH on October 1st. “No” prices have skyrocketed in the last
week from 50% to 88%.

Own a CryptoPunk and looking to hedge? Think CryptoPunks prices will
recover over the next 2 weeks and want to take a long position? Head over
to Polymarket and start trading today. For a limited time, sign up with
referral code “Pomp” to get your first trade reimbursed up to $100.

TRY IT HERE: Click here to get started.

THE RUNDOWN:

US Regulators Looking to Get a Handle on Stablecoins, NY Times Says: Saying the rush to bring stablecoins under regulatory control might be “the most important conversation in Washington financial circles this year,” the New York Times published an explainer article on the type of cryptocurrency and laid out what the author (and perhaps her sources) sees as the top options at regulators’ disposal. Read more.

Biden Administration Plans Cryptocurrency Sanctions to Combat Ransomware: The U.S. government plans to issue guidance and impose sanctions in an ongoing effort to tamp down on ransomware attacks. The Wall Street Journal reported Friday that the Joe Biden administration is planning an array of actions to mitigate ransomware attacks, with a focus on payments. The Treasury Department will announce these actions next week, CoinDesk confirmed. Read more.

Bakkt to Go Public Next Month After SEC Okays SPAC Plans: Bakkt Holdings and VPC Impact Acquisition Holdings have received approval from the Securities and Exchange Commission to complete their merger and push forward with plans to operate as a single publicly traded entity, the companies said in an announcement Friday. VIH shareholders will meet on Oct. 14 to approve the merger, the companies said. Cryptocurrency exchange Bakkt, which is majority-owned by Intercontinental Exchange, has been planning to go public via the merger with VIH, a special purpose acquisition company. Read more.

Christie’s to Sell Some of the Earliest NFTs – And Only for ETH: Christie’s is listing a set of 31 Curio Cards and several other prominent non-fungible token (NFT) projects in a live auction on Oct. 1, furthering its foray into digital art sales. The 254-year-old auction house made history in March when it auctioned a Beeple NFT for $69 million. Christie’s Asia branch is now taking bids for several rare CryptoPunks and Bored Ape NFTs as recent buyer appetite for NFTs approaches manic levels. Read more.

LISTEN TO THIS EPISODE OF THE POMP PODCAST HERE

Kyle Samani is a Co-Founder and Managing Partner at Multicoin Capital, a thesis-driven investment firm with a global footprint that invests exclusively in the crypto ecosystem. Multicoin Capital manages several billion in assets across hedge funds and venture funds.

In this conversation, we discuss Bitcoin, Ethereum, Solana, crypto investment thesis, and how Kyle sees the future unfolding in crypto.

LISTEN TO THIS EPISODE OF THE POMP PODCAST HERE

Podcast Sponsors

These companies make the podcast possible, so go check them out and thank them for their support!

1. Polymarket - Polymarket is the world’s leading information markets platform where you can trade on the most pressing global questions and see unbiased, real-time data on what the market thinks will happen – all on the blockchain. Will Cardano support smart contracts by October? Will the US have more than 100,00 covid cases before 2022? For a limited time, sign up with referral code “Pomp” to get your first trade reimbursed up to $100. Click here to get started!

2. Cosmos is building the Internet of Blockchains, marking a new era of interoperability, scalability, and usability. The free flow of assets and data between blockchains with bridges to Ethereum and Bitcoin will unleash the potential of DeFi, NFTs, and much more. Dive into Cosmos at cosmos.network/pomp

3. Choice is a new self-directed IRA product that allows you to buy Bitcoin with tax-advantaged dollars, while still holding your private keys. You can go to retirewithchoice.com/pomp to sign up today.

4. BlockFi provides financial products for crypto investors. Products include high-yield interest accounts, USD loans, and no fee trading. To start earning today visit: http://www.blockfi.com/Pomp

5. Crypto.com allows you to buy, sell, store, earn, loan, and invest various cryptocurrencies in an user friendly mobile app. Join over one million users today. You can download and earn $50 USD with my code “pomp2020” when you sign up for one of their metal cards today.

6. Circle is a global financial technology firm that enables businesses of all sizes to harness the power of stablecoins and public blockchains for payments, commerce and financial applications worldwide. Circle is also a principal developer of USD Coin (USDC), the fastest growing, fully reserved and regulated dollar stablecoin in the world. The free Circle Account and suite of platform API services bridge the gap between traditional payments and crypto for trading, DeFi, and NFT marketplaces. Create seamless, user-friendly, mainstream customer experiences with crypto-native infrastructure under the hood with Circle. Learn more at circle.com.

7. Gemini is a leading regulated cryptocurrency exchange, wallet, and custodian that makes it simple and secure to buy bitcoin, ether, and over 30 other cryptocurrencies. Offering industry-leading security, insurance and uptime, Gemini is the go-to trusted platform for beginner and sophisticated investors alike. Open a free account in under 3 minutes at gemini.com/pomp and get $20 of bitcoin after you trade $100 or more within 30 days.

8. LMAX Digital - the market-leading solution for institutional crypto trading & custodial services - offers clients a regulated, transparent and secure trading environment, together with the deepest pool of crypto liquidity. LMAX Digital is also a primary price discovery venue, streaming real-time market data to the industry’s leading analytics platforms. LMAX Digital - secure, liquid, trusted. Learn more at LMAXdigital.com/pomp

9. Mask Network - The portal to the new, open internet. Building on top of the existing social networks, the Mask extension allows borderless cryptocurrency transfer, decentralized file storage and sharing, decentralized finance, and many other features that were once impossible to interact with on traditional social media. Visit mask.io/pomp and use the extension to start exploring the decentralized application world.

10. Okcoin - Okcoin is one of the most popular licensed exchanges. Okcoin is the first to bring new cryptos to market, offering some of the lowest fees in the industry, an easy to use app, and Earn feature! It’s easier than ever to sign up, buy and trade crypto in just 2 minutes on Okcoin with credit & debit cards or just link your bank account to the best new crypto assets. So get started, and go to okcoin.com/pomp

11. Matrixport - Matrixport is Asia’s fastest growing digital asset platform with $10 billion in assets under management and custody. It offers one-stop crypto financial solutions including fixed income, DeFi in 1-click, structured products, Cactus Custody™, spot OTC and lending. Go download the Matrixport App and enjoy a welcome offer of  30% APY on USDC for new users. 

12. Miami Makers Month is a virtual hackathon for hackers, designers, and creators who are passionate about creating apps to benefit the City of Miami. $25k in total prizes will be awarded to developers who build the winning apps on MiamiCoin -- a community-launched platform for innovation built on Bitcoin, and Stacks. Visit MiamiMakers.co to learn more and get involved.

13. Masterworks - Masterworks.io is the leading platform for blue-chip art investing with over 185,000 registered users. They have purchased over $180MM in art from artists like Banksy, Basquiat and KAWS.

You are receiving The Pomp Letter because you either signed up or you attended one of the events that I spoke at. Feel free to unsubscribe if you aren’t finding this valuable.

Nothing in this email is intended to serve as financial advice. Do your own research.