Crosswords and copyright; Politician seeks restraining order against critic who called her ‘political prostitute’ and ‘honey’; Is it a crime to encourage an audience to physically attack hecklers?; Is it a crime to heckle at a campaign rally?;
 
The Volokh Conspiracy
 
 
Crosswords and copyright
A fascinating plagiarism scandal in the strange and esoteric world of crossword puzzle construction sheds some interesting light on what we mean by "plagiarism," and how that relates to what we mean by "copyright infringement."
ADVERTISEMENT
 
Politician seeks restraining order against critic who called her ‘political prostitute’ and ‘honey’
The plaintiff is Baldwin Park mayor pro tem and council member Monica Garcia -- and Mayor Manuel Lozano and council member Ricardo Pacheco are seeking restraining orders against defendant Greg Tuttle on related grounds. Garcia also claims Tuttle followed her and her colleagues to a conference and a post-conference dinner -- but critics should be free to track what politicians are doing at such events, just as journalists and opposition researchers do.
Is it a crime to encourage an audience to physically attack hecklers?
Probably yes -- either incitement or solicitation -- if the speaker is calling for attacking just hecklers. Probably no if the speaker is calling for moderate defense against people who are throwing things, who are punching or shoving, or who are shouting down the speaker.
 
Is it a crime to heckle at a campaign rally?
Yes, if the heckling shouts down the speaker, or otherwise seriously interferes with the event. Probably not, if it's just the occasional catcall (or maybe even more). But on private property, the heckler can be ordered to leave, and can be prosecuted for trespass if he doesn't.
Jury nullification instructions coming to New Hampshire?
Last week, the N.H. lower house passed a bill that would require courts to instruct jurors about jury nullification -- the jurors' power to refuse to convict even when they think all the elements of the crime have been proved beyond a reasonable doubt.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
 
Recommended for you
 
Fact Checker
Count the pinocchios. A weekly review of what's true, false or in-between.
Sign Up »
 
     
 
©2016 The Washington Post, 1301 K St NW, Washington DC 20071