View this email in your browser
5/24/2021

Beginning this week’s curation is our latest 1776 Series essay, “The Right of Revolution in the American Founding.” In this richly informative essay, Kevin Portteus explains a central but often overlooked principle in the Declaration of Independence: the right of revolution. He contends that revolution need not entail overthrowing all of civilization. Instead, through words and actions, the American Founders prudentially exercised this right, which they understood to be based on an unchanging standard of justice. Governments, the Declaration declares, should not be challenged or overthrown for “light and transient causes.” To clarify his argument, Portteus contrasts the success of the American Revolution with its bloody alternatives in France and Russia, which had disastrous consequences for the citizens of both countries.

Peter Wood takes on critiques of America’s principles and practices launched by the 1619 Project and practitioners of critical race theory such as Ibram X. Kendi and Robin DiAngelo. Wood counters those various critics by arguing that America’s “long traditions of antislavery, abolition, and dedication to a civic equality that transcends race” has made it “one of the least racist countries in the world,” as “citizens of all races have achieved extraordinary prosperity and liberty.”

Walter McDougall explains the foreign policy that animated the American Founders, which is commonly (and wrongly) thought to be isolationist. Instead, the Founders were concerned with keeping other nations from influencing the U.S. in order to preserve the nation’s freedom of action to protect and preserve its interests. As McDougall argues, U.S. foreign policy in the early republic was guided by four core tenets: “liberty at home, but no foreign crusades; neutrality dictating no entangling alliances; a separate American system of states codified in the Monroe Doctrine; and continental expansion on the principle that the Constitution follows the flag.”

Original Posts

The Right of Revolution in the American Founding

Kevin Portteus, RealClearPublicAffairs

According to the American Declaration of Independence, people enter into political society for the sake of protecting their...

Essential Reading

Promised Land: US Foreign Policy in the Founding

Walter A. McDougall, Modern Age

Who are we, we Americans? Are we champions of liberty, both civil and religious, both at home and abroad? Are we a nation of...

In the News

Was Thomas Jefferson America’s First Abolitionist?

Robert F. Turner, Minding the Campus

New Tool for States to Block Action Civics and CRT

Stanley Kurtz, National Review

Where Is the Charles Evans Hughes of 2021?

John Maxwell Hamilton & Bruce Sanford, RealClearPolitics

The Right Way to Fight Racism

Emilie Kao, Daily Signal

Is Biden's Jimmy Carter Impression an Opportunity for Reagan 2.0?

Brad Lips, RealClearPolicy

Who's on Pres. Biden's Supreme Court Commission?

Tyler Olsen, Fox News

Your Trump-Loving Uncle Is Not Evil (and Neither Is Your Biden-Loving Aunt)

Ciaran O'Connor, Deseret News

A New History Curriculum or Anti-American Propaganda?

Lindsey Burke, Mike Gonzalez, & Jonathan Butcher, Sacramento Bee

After Capitol Riot, Some States Turn to Civics Education

Matt Vasilogambros, Pew

Forgotten Constitutional Clause Could Change Census Outcome

Thomas Berry, The Hill

What Should Florida Kids learn About U.S. History?

Jeffrey S. Solochek, Tampa Bay Times

Blacks Wrongly Focus on Racism

Jesse Turner, Arkansas Democrat Gazette

Invest More Than a Nickel in Civics Education

Randall Trammell, Atlanta Journal-Constitution

What Is Critical Race Theory, and Why Is It Under Attack?

Stephen Sawchuk, Education Week

Clashes On CRT Obscure Real Causes of Education Inequity

Natalie Wexler, Forbes

Multimedia

Primary Source Close Reads: Eisenhower's Farewell Address

Kirk Higgins & Stephen Tootle, Bill of Rights Institute

Who was Dwight D. Eisenhower? While perhaps not discussed as often as other 20th century presidents, Eisenhower led the...

Great Ideas Debate: Socialism or Capitalism?

Richard Wolff & Arthur Brooks, Abigail Adams Institute

This is a recording of the second annual Great Ideas Debate in conjunction with the Intercollegiate Studies Institute and the...

Plymouth Colony Pilgrims

Richard Pickering, CSPAN

At Plimoth Patuxet in Plymouth, Massachusetts, we explored the recreated 17th-century colonial village and spoke with interpreters...

Balance and Perspective on Race

John McWhorter & John Wood, Braver Angels

John McWhorter is a professor of linguistics at Columbia University, the author of many books, a witty and passionately independent...

Critical Race Theory Is the Wrong Way To Discuss Race

Allen Guelzo, Fox News

Allen Guelzo joined The Story with Martha MacCallum on Fox News to discuss the dangers of using critical race theory in school...

Podcast: God’s in His Heaven

Chris Flannery, American Story

Twenty-Twenty seems to have spread like a virus into 2021. A third of the way through the year and still across the country citizens...

1787: The Constitutional Convention and Political Participation in the Early Republic

Eric Nelson, James Stoner, Jack Rakove, et al., National Association of Scholars

In 1787, fifty-five delegates from the states met in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, to chart a new course for the nation. The Articles of...

Podcast: Locke, Tocqueville, and Civic Education

Jeffrey Sikkenga & Nino Scalia, Madison's Notes

Why is education so important in a democracy? Are democracies capable of producing the citizens they need? What do John Locke...

Debate on Religious Liberty, Non-Discrimination Laws

Braver Angels

Hundreds of liberal and conservative Americans gathered on May 13th to debate whether or not they believe non-discrimination laws...

Constitution Bowl 2021

U.S. Constitution Scholarship Foundation

The U.S. Constitution Bowl provides an opportunity for teams from all Nassau County (Florida) School District high schools and home school...

Carl Cannon's Great American Stories

Great American Stories: When Morse Logged On

On this date in 1844, Samuel Morse sent the first public message via telegraph. It went over the newly installed wire on Capitol ...

Great American Stories: Amelia Earhart's Quote

Good morning, it's Friday, May 21, 2021, the day of the week when I reprise quotations intended to be uplifting ...

Great American Stories: Chic's Call

Forty-eight years ago today, racetrack announcer Chic Anderson had a very good day. So did the star of his television ...

Having trouble viewing this email? | [Unsubscribe] | Update Subscription Preferences 

You are receiving this email because you signed up the Public Affairs Civics Newsletter

Copyright © 2021 RealClearHoldings, All rights reserved.
RealClearHoldings
666 Dundee Road
Bldg. 600
Northbrook, IL 60062