View this email in your browser
11/1/2021

This week’s curation at RealClear’s American Civics portal begins with the latest piece in our ongoing civic institution series. American Civics portal editor Mike Sabo highlights the Tocqueville Program at Furman University. Co-directed by Professors Benjamin and Jenna Storey, the program offers students an education in the enduring ideas that have animated the best minds in philosophy, history, and politics for millennia. Through “exploring the moral and philosophic questions at the heart of political life,” students can rise to practice the art of self-government in their communities, towns, and cities.

In light of the impending removal of Thomas Jefferson’s statue in New York City Hall, many responses have been flooding in that oppose this move. Historian Sean Wilentz writes that though Jefferson was a man of contradictions and sometimes great flaws, his triumphs such as authoring the Declaration of Independence, which includes the crucial yet “simple assertion that all men are created equal,” should be publicly celebrated. Wilentz prefers the statue to stay “in City Hall, where it’s stood for nearly two hundred years, as a symbol of the democratic values that New Yorkers hold dear.”

Samuel Goldman contends that the “removal is disgraceful” and that Jefferson “is clearly being honored for composing an immortal argument for liberty and equality,” not his moral shortcomings. He also argues that removing the statue “diminishes the ideals” Jefferson “came to embody and the many Americans who feel a deep and abiding connection with them,” especially Jews.

Jews have historically been a “widely despised and persecuted people who thrived in America like nowhere else” and thus “do not fit into the sharp distinction between oppressor and oppressed that characterized ideological ‘antiracism,’” Goldman notes. According to the ideology behind the statue’s removal, “Therefore, Jewish experiences must either be ignored or reduced to a monolithic conception of white supremacy.”

Quoting George Santayana’s famous dictum, “Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it,” Roger L. Simon argues that removing the statue could increase the future possibility of taking down the statues of other American heroes such as Benjamin Franklin, whom he calls “America’s own DaVinci.”

Original Posts

The Tocqueville Program Fosters Self-Governing Citizens

Mike Sabo, RealClearWire

Essential Reading

Shelby Steele: American Humanist

Samuel Kronen, City Journal

For more than three decades, best-selling author and Hoover Institution senior fellow Shelby Steele has illuminated the psychology...

In the News

The Radicalism of James Madison

Jay Cost, Wall Street Journal

Historians Gordon Wood and Woody Holton Clash Over American History

Hillel Italie, ABC News

The Reality of Shared Stories

Wilfred M. McClay, Law & Liberty

'Woke Racism': A Review

Jared Marcel Pollen, Quillette

The Right Way to Reject Critical Race Theory

Frederick Hess, The Dispatch

The 'Nuanced' History of Thomas Jefferson

Jeff Jacoby, Jewish World Review

Five Facts on Budget Reconciliation

No Labels, RealClearPolicy

Clamorous Students Participate in Government By Suing It

Jennifers McDermott, AP

Their Ideology and Ours

Shoshana Bryen, Newsweek

Judge Pryor’s Friendly Fire

Hadley Arkes, Law & Liberty

Can the Constitution be Colorblind?

Ken Masugi, Teaching American History

Noem Puts SD Standards on a Dangerous Path

Stanley Kurtz, National Review

Blacks Didn't Fight Alongside White Confederates

Scott W. Stern, New Republic

Modeling Respect and Empathy Makes a Difference

Doug Teschner, New Hampshire Business Review

The War on Jefferson—Is Franklin Next?

Roger L. Simon, Epoch Times

Multimedia

Robert E. Lee: A Life

Allen Guelzo, NPR

'Robert E. Lee: A Life' is a new biography that examines one of the most well-known and controversial Civil War figures. Author...

How Should We Interpret the Constitution?

Donald Drakeman & Jeff Sikkenga, American Idea

In this episode of The American Idea, Jeff welcomes Donald Drakeman, Distinguished Research Professor at the University of Notre Dame and the Founding Chairman of the Advisory Council of the

For Such a Time as This

Chris Flannery, American Story

I had some time on my hands, and before I knew it, I had time on my mind. Time flies, marches on, and sometimes just stands still...

The Biden Supreme Court Commission

Jamal Greene, Michael McConnell, & Jeffrey Rosen, National Constitution Center

On April 9, 2021, President Biden issued Executive Order 14023 forming the Presidential Commission on the Supreme Court...

Justice Thomas’ Thirty-Year Legacy on the Court

Justice Clarence Thomas, Heritage Foundation

The Heritage Foundation and the C. Boyden Gray Center for the Study of the Administrative State at Antonin Scalia Law School hosts...

The Unraveling of America Post-Revolution

Michael Warren, Patriot Week

Learn how American liberty was threatened following the American Revolution. Explore how the Articles of Confederation...

Carl Cannon's Great American Stories

Great American Stories: Laird Hamilton's Quote

Nearly six decades ago, a young guitarist who went by the name of Dick Dale began playing dance music at ...

Great American Stories: What Volstead Wrought

On this date in 1919, Congress overrode Woodrow Wilson's veto to pass the Volstead Act, which set in place the ...

Great American Stories: Baseball's Ralph Kiner

It's late in the year to be reporting that the first game of the World Series has taken place and ...

Having trouble viewing this email? | [Unsubscribe] | Update Subscription Preferences 

You are receiving this email because you signed up the Public Affairs Civics Newsletter

Copyright © 2021 RealClearHoldings, All rights reserved.
RealClearHoldings
666 Dundee Road
Bldg. 600
Northbrook, IL 60062