THE DAILY NEWSLETTER - WEDNESDAY, AUGUST 18, 2021 

Media Winners & Losers

MEDIA WINNER:
Clarissa Ward

CNN's Clarissa Ward has already been a Media Winner once during the fall of Afghanistan to the Taliban. In the subsequent days there were a dozen reasons she could have won the day again for the compelling, on-the-ground reporting she’s filing from the streets of Kabul.

She could have been named the winner for daring to question a Taliban “spokesperson” on face covering mandates for women. Or for continuing to uncover her face while reporting despite the Taliban already clamping down on women in the country.

She could be named winner for her unique and fearless assessment of Joe Biden‘s speech, and how citizens of Afghanistan are likely to react to it. Or for confronting a Pentagon spokesperson and demanding answers for the people still trapped behind Taliban lines. Or for doing both of those things without regard to or being influenced by unfair attacks from politicians and pundits at home.

Certainly Ward deserves a media win for her incredible poise and composure as gunfire erupts around her, or for how she and her cameraman continue doing their important work even as threats are leveled directly and explicitly at them.

But Ward wins today for the moment, in this report, when she has on a translator who worked with Americans, and the man shows his actual Green Card on camera.

Amid all the chaos in the streets, the gunfire and threats both in Kabul and in D.C., amid hundreds of reports and personal accounts, Ward delivered an on-street report that showed in stark, visible, terms that anyone who sees it can understand.

What Clarissa Ward and her cameraman are capturing is worth a thousand words scribbled here on our shores. She showed the human being behind the rhetoric, the at-risk Afghan citizen, one of thousands and thousands, who are suffering now.

Ward’s reporting from Afghanistan could be a media win every day this week. She’s the winner today because so many are losing right now, and she’s telling their stories. At risk, and under fire. That’s reporting. That’s journalism.

MEDIA LOSER:
One America News (OAN)

One America News has faced another loss in their legal battle against MSNBC’s Rachel Maddow.

On Tuesday, the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals upheld a previous court ruling that determined Maddow’s statements regarding the far-right, pro-Donald Trump network were not actionable.

OAN, owned by Herring Networks, first sued Maddow for $10 million in 2019 after the anchor labeled the network as “paid Russian propaganda.”

The suit slammed her comments as “malicious and utterly false,” despite the fact that they were based on a Daily Beast report that noted OAN employs reporter Kristian Rouz, who also worked for Kremlin-owned media outlet Sputnik.

“We literally learned today that that outlet the President is promoting shares staff with the Kremlin,” Maddow said following news of the Beast’s report, adding, “In this case, the most obsequiously pro-Trump right wing news outlet in America really literally is paid Russian propaganda. Their on-air U.S. politics reporter is paid by the Russian government to produce propaganda for that government.”

OAN maintained, however, that the network “is wholly financed by the Herrings, an American family” and “has never been paid or received a penny from Russia or the Russian government,” justifying their defamation suit.

A federal judge dismissed the suit in May 2020, concluding that Maddow’s statement was “an opinion that cannot serve as the basis for a defamation claim.”

Following through with judge’s grant, MSNBC and Maddow requested that OAN pay $350,000 in legal fees. In February, the court permanently dismissed the case and awarded the defendants $247,667.50.

Despite the ruling, OAN president Charles Herring was “highly confident” that the network would “receive a favorable and just ruling in the US Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit.”

Well, Herring’s prediction was off the mark. By a lot.

The network is not having good luck in court this year, and is one of the targets of a massive lawsuit from Dominion Voting Systems.

The A-Block

Top Biden Officials To Testify About Afghanistan

Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi revealed that top Biden administration officials will testify before Congress on the chaotic evacuation of Afghanistan, at hearings to begin next week.

House Foreign Relations Committee Chair Rep. Gregory Meeks of New York released a statement Tuesday announcing that he has invited Secretary of State Antony Blinken and Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin to testify at a hearing “as early as possible,” and on Tuesday night, Pelosi narrowed that timeframe down.

During a lengthy interview with San Francisco CBS affiliate KPIX, co-anchor Juliette Goodrich told Pelosi that “even if ending the U.S. military presence in Afghanistan was the right decision, as President Biden insists, many are still questioning how it was carried out,” and asked, on behalf of a viewer, “Will there be a congressional investigation into the withdrawal from Afghanistan?”

“The chair of our Foreign Affairs Committee has announced today, to our caucus that there would, next week, early next week, be a hearing on this subject with the highest level of officials in the Biden administration,” Speaker Pelosi said.

“That is Congress’s role, the role of oversight. And that will take place early next week, at least, it will begin then,” Pelosi added.

Watch the full clip and read Meeks' statements here.

 
In Other News...

The Shortlist of New Names for the Washington Football Team is Out, And They're Just as Awful as You Thought They'd Be

Employees of Pro-Socialist Magazine Current Affairs Claim They Were Fired Starting a Workers Co-Op

'CNN's Brianna Keilar Dedicates Thread to Afghans Who Kept Her Husband Alive While He Served in Their Country

CHRISTOPHER: Maggie Haberman Retweets Trump Attack Ad Showing Afghans Falling to Their Deaths

Must See Clip

"Are you a good little Nazi?!"

“You do not get a vaccine passport put on us!” shouts the unidentified dreadlocked man in a Statue of Liberty t-shirt in this clip. “You know, as the population who’s in control, you know that the people are the politicians once you get a power you will never relinquish it!"

"Do you think that the four feet of marble that holds you above, high in this chamber will help you from the fate of humanity which you are unleashing?!" he yells at the top of his lungs. "Noooo! It won’t! Your children and your children's children will be subjugated, and be asked:

"'HOW MANY VACCINES HAVE YOU HAD? HAVE YOU BEEN A GOOD LITTLE NAZI!?

So, you know, super normal day there.

Links We Like

The Experts Got It Wrong And Biden Lacks The Humility To Admit It
- Erick Erickson, Substack
In the Taliban’s Birthplace, White Flags, Jailbreaks and Fears of Revenge
- Shelly Kittleson, Politico
Rather Than Focus on How the US Got Out of Afghanistan, Focus on How It Got In
- Katrina vanden Heuvel, The Nation
To Move Forward After Ella French’s Death, Chicago Must Address Root Causes Of Gun Violence
- Arne Duncan, Chicago Tribune
Reading this online? Why not get it in your inbox? Sign up for the Mediaite Live from the Greenroom Newsletter today!
Twitter Twitter
Facebook Facebook
Instagram Instagram
Visit Mediaite Visit Mediaite
Copyright © 2021 Mediaite LLC All rights reserved.

Write to us:  tips@mediaite.com

Problems with these e-mails? Update your preferences or unsubscribe from this list.