There was no consensus but three stood out as favorites.  

The Chocolate Raspberry Buttercream Cupcake.  This is a great cupcake with its raspberry cream filling. Everyone likes it but I'm not sure that passions run deep.  

The Maple Bacon Cupcake.  This is the love/hate cupcake.  It's a maple chocolate cupcake topped with candied bacon.  

I offered these to two women.  One said, "That's disgusting," and wouldn't touch it.

The Chunky Monkey Cupcake.  No dissenters here.  It's a banana cupcake with nuts and chocolate chips and a banana cream filling.  

This cupcake is so different and so good that folks do get passionate about it. It's number one.

But make them.  See how they rank in your family.