Israel has fallen into Hamas' trap. But there's a way out
Opinion Editor's Choice
 
View in browser
 
 
Israeli soldiers operating in February, amid the ongoing war between Israel and Hamas, in the Gaza Strip
 
Dina Kraft  
Dina Kraft
 
 
Ramadan has begun and in Gaza, hunger and desperation only grows. In Israel, hopelessness also mounts. Soldiers continue to die, most of the 200,000 internally displaced are no closer to returning home, especially in the north, as tensions with Hezbollah intensify. Itay Chen, a dual U.S.-Israeli citizen, one of the hostages, was declared dead after Israeli officials confirmed he was killed October 7. His body was taken by Hamas.

Many have been taken aback by the seemingly callous attitude towards the hostages by Israel's government. Ishay Rosen-Zvi gives insight into why, arguing that for Israel's rising jingoistic, messianic religious right, the war in Gaza is about recovering pride and projecting power. Desperate hostages held by Hamas don't fit their narrative.

Etan Nechin takes on the controversy of philosopher Judith Butler's recent comments, and how it reflects a crisis in left-wing thinking about Israelis and Palestinians – not least by the self-styled "radicals." Andrea Mammone posits that Italy and France's far right parties have seized on the Gaza war to ramp up their pro-Israel posturing, despite the neofascist antisemitism entrenched in their political milieu and calls for Jews to reject their "allyship."

Page Fortna writes that beating that beating Hamas requires unconventional thinking, and suggests that Israel provide massive amounts of humanitarian aid to shelter and feed Palestinians in safe havens, including within Israel proper.

Eva Illouz and Tamar Hostovsky Brandes criticize the disproportionate power the ultra-Orthodox have, arguing no country has such a dysfunctional social contract like Israel does.
 
 
 
 
podcast icon
PODCAST | Franklin Foer: 'Everyday Jewish life in the U.S. will be punctuated by antisemitism'
 
LISTEN
 
 
 
 
 
A wall covered in posters of Israeli hostages being held in Gaza by Hamas and the yellow ribbons that symbolize the campaign for their return.
 
 
Why Israel's New Nationalistic Judaism Doesn't Care About the Hostages in Gaza
Ishay Rosen-Zvi | 13.03.2024
 
 
 
 
 
From left to right, far right leaders, Marine Le Pen, leader of France's National Rally party, Giorgia Meloni, prime minister of Italy, and Eric Zemmour, leader of France's Reconquête party.
 
 
Why the Far Right in France and Italy Rally Around an Israel at War
Andrea Mammone | 13.03.2024
 
 
 
 
 
An Israeli soldier watches a Haredi protest in front of the Institute of Forensic Medicine in Tel Aviv, this month.
 
 
In Israel, non-Orthodox Citizens Serve the State and the State Serves the ultra-Orthodox
Eva Illouz | 13.03.2024
 
 
 
 
 
Palestinian children wait to receive food, last month, cooked by a charity kitchen amid shortages of food supplies in Rafah, in the southern Gaza Strip.
 
 
Israel Has Fallen Into Hamas' Trap. But There's a Way Out
Page Fortna | 13.03.2024
 
 
 
 
 
na
 
 
Why Judith Butler Calling Hamas' Slaughter 'Armed Resistance' Is So Depressing
Etan Nechin | 13.03.2024
 
 
Haaretz.com - הארץ
 
Facebook Twitter RSS Newsletter Apple Android
 
Unsubscribe from mailing list.
For more Haaretz newsletters, click here.
or contact support: digital-english@haaretz.co.il
Unsubscribe from all mailing lists
All rights reserved © Haaretz Daily Newspaper Ltd.
Schocken ­21, Tel - Aviv, ­6653207­, Israel.
Company Registration No. ­51-­001544-­9.